MPs raise concerns about French-language directive in Quebec health care
Two MPs are raising concerns about directives given to health sector workers on French-language use in Quebec institutions.
Notre-Dame-de-Grâce—Westmount MP Anna Gainey and Mount Royal MP Anthony Housefather took to social media to share concerns from some Quebecers who fear they will not be able to receive medical treatment in a language other than French.
"When it comes to health care, the language preferred by the patient is paramount," Housefather wrote on X.
"This directive seems to imply that you need English-language eligibility except if you're in exceptional situations and that's very problematic," Housefather told CTV News. Gainey posted a statement saying that she has spoken with legal experts as well as health and social services providers and advocates "to understand the impact of the recent Quebec directive on situations in which a language other than French may be used in the health and social service network."
She added that she spoke to federal Health Minister Mark Holland about the directive.
"They are very worried because the directive would interfere with effective communication between them and their caregivers," Gainey said. "The scientific evidence is overwhelming; effective communication is an essential component for the delivery of safe and effective health and social services."
Quebec French language minister Jean-François Roberge responded to criticism of the directives at the end of July and again on Tuesday took to social media to defend the policy.
"It is imperative to take strong action to ensure the vitality of the French language and this is what we have been doing since 2018," he wrote on X. "It is important to reiterate, however, that when it comes to health, the government imposes absolutely no language conditions before providing care in English to anyone who requests it."
Gainey wrote in her statement that the federal government will be prepared to insist upon patients being able to receive care in both official languages.
"The Quebec Health and Social Services Network has the capacity to provide and has been providing for decades services in both official languages based on the preferred language of service of the individual," wrote Gainey. "While the precise impact of the directive on English-speaking people in Quebec remains undetermined, it is clear that the confusion and uncertainty created by the directive is likely to have adverse consequences that cannot be ignored. Clarity is urgently needed."
Directives 'put people's health and security in jeopardy,' legal expert says
Constitutional lawyer Frédéric Bérard said Gainey's argument is interesting but added that if English speakers in Quebec need to be accommodated, all French-speaking people would need to be accommodated across Canada.
He said, however, that the problem with the directives is that they encroach on the security that is protected by the Canadian and Quebec charters of rights.
"Think about it. You go to the emergency, the public servants have to follow the directive 100 per cent. They don't have any discretion on that," said Bérard . "They have to apply it, right? If they don't do so, they can lose their job, so they will apply the directive."
If a patient does not have their English certificate of eligibility due to it being elsewhere or if they have not applied for it, Bérard said, the patient's safety and security could be at risk.
"This directive is not only unconstitutional, but it's also nonsense in the way that you're just trying to divide people for no reason," he said. "The only reason why they do that is for political gains. And say, 'We're protecting French,' but there's no way you protect French and put people's health and security in jeopardy."
Bérard added that it's unreasonable to assume a health-care worker has read and understood every exemption in the 31-page directive.
"Do you seriously think that the nurse working at the emergency would have read the whole 31 pages and will remember each exception provided by the 31-page directive?" he said. "Don't you think that those nurses, doctors have quite enough on their shoulders right now not to try to interpret a directive that is that long?"
With reporting from CTV News journalist Matt Gilmour.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
![](https://www.ctvnews.ca/polopoly_fs/1.7031475.1725923234!/httpImage/image.png_gen/derivatives/landscape_800/image.png)
2 hospitalized, suspects sought after 'extreme case of road rage' in B.C.: RCMP
Mounties in B.C.'s Lower Mainland are searching for two people allegedly responsible for a road rage incident that sent a couple to hospital with serious injuries, saying the suspects could be in another province.
Why is this village in Quebec facing a 370 per cent property tax hike?
Residents in the small Quebec village of Danford Lake may soon be priced out of their homes, as property valuations and taxes are set to skyrocket.
Calgary's police chief speaks out against Alberta's anticipated photo radar crackdown
Calgary’s police chief has issued a grave warning about the potential impact of further restrictions on photo radar use in Alberta.
Woman who died in B.C. jail cell had asked to be taken to hospital twice, report shows
A woman who died from drug toxicity while in a B.C. jail cell asked to be taken to hospital twice in the hours after she was taken into custody in a case the province's police watchdog says again raises concerns over the treatment of intoxicated prisoners.
James Earl Jones, acclaimed actor and voice of Darth Vader, dies at 93
James Earl Jones, who overcame racial prejudice and a severe stutter to become a celebrated icon of stage and screen — eventually lending his deep, commanding voice to CNN, 'The Lion King' and Darth Vader — has died. He was 93.
Romeo Dallaire now recovered from severe infection: CTV News Exclusive
Romeo Dallaire is ready to return to public life again this fall after a serious health scare forced the retired lieutenant-general to postpone his cross-country book tour in March.
White Stripes sue Donald Trump over use of 'Seven Nation Army' riff in social media post
The White Stripes sued former U.S. president Donald Trump on Monday in a case that alleges he used their hit song 'Seven Nation Army' without permission in a video posted to social media.
Alberta protesters get 6 1/2-year sentences for roles in Coutts border blockade
One of two men sentenced Monday to 6 1/2 years for firearms violations and mischief at the border blockade at Coutts, Alta., says the time he has already spent behind bars has changed him and his "solemn weapon” is now love.
'You can't miss Luke Skywalker': Mark Hamill spotted filming in Manitoba town
Star Wars icon Mark Hamill rode through the streets of Stonewall, Man. last month filming scenes atop what looked to be an Army vehicle for the upcoming film adaptation of Stephen King's "The Long Walk."