Air Canada denying passenger compensation claims for staff shortages, citing safety
Less than four hours before departure, Ryan Farrell was surprised to learn his flight from Yellowknife to Calgary had been cancelled.
Air Canada cited "crew constraints" and rebooked him on a plane leaving 48 hours after the June 17 flight's original takeoff time.
Farrell was even more surprised six weeks later, when he learned his request for compensation had been denied on the basis of the staff shortage.
"Since your Air Canada flight was delayed/cancelled due to crew constraints resulting from the impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on our operations, the compensation you are requesting does not apply because the delay/cancellation was caused by a safety-related issue," reads the email from customer relations dated July 29.
The rejection "feels like a slap in the face," Farrell said.
"If they don't have replacement crew to substitute in, then the flight (was) cancelled because they failed to assemble a crew, not because any other factor would have made it inherently unsafe to run the flight," he said in an email.
"I think the airlines are trying to exploit a general emotional connection that people make between `COVID-19' and `safety,' when in reality if you put their logic to the test it doesn't stand up."
Air Canada's response to Farrell's complaint was no outlier. In a Dec. 29 memo, the company instructed employees to classify flight cancellations caused by staff shortages as a "safety" problem, which would exclude travellers from compensation under federal regulations. That policy remains in place.
Canada's passenger rights charter, the Air Passenger Protection Regulations (APPR), mandates airlines to pay up to $1,000 in compensation for cancellations or significant delays that stem from reasons within the carrier's control when the notification comes 14 days or less before departure. However, airlines do not have to pay if the change was required for safety purposes.
The Canadian Transportation Agency (CTA), a quasi-judicial federal body, says treating staff shortages as a safety matter violates federal rules.
"If a crew shortage is due to the actions or inactions of the carrier, the disruption will be considered within the carrier's control for the purposes of the APPR. Therefore, a disruption caused by a crew shortage should not be considered 'required for safety purposes' when it is the carrier who caused the safety issue as a result of its own actions," the agency said in an email.
That stance reinforces a decision made July 8 -- three weeks before Farrell learned he'd been denied compensation -- when the CTA used nearly identical language in a dispute over a flight at a different air carrier. The regulatory panel's ruling in that case emphasized airlines' obligations around advance planning "to ensure that the carrier has enough staff available to operate the services it offers for sale."
In the December memo, which was issued at the height of the Omicron wave of COVID-19, Air Canada said: "Effective immediately, flight cancellations due to crew are considered as Within Carrier Control -- For Safety."
"Customers impacted by these flight cancellations will still be eligible for the standard of treatments such as hotel accommodations, meals etc. but will no longer be eligible for APPR claims/monetary compensation."
The staff directive said the stance would be "temporary." But Air Canada acknowledged in an email on July 25 that the policy "remains in place given the continued exceptional circumstances brought on by COVID variants."
Gabor Lukacs, president of the Air Passenger Rights advocacy group, said Air Canada is "unlawfully" exploiting the passenger rights charter to avoid paying compensation and called on the transport regulator for stronger enforcement.
"They are misclassifying things that are clearly not a safety issue," he said of Canada's largest airline, calling the policy "egregious."
Consumers can dispute an airline's denial of a claim via a complaint to the CTA. However, the agency's backlog topped 15,300 air travel complaints as of May.
Lukacs also noted that European Union regulations do not exclude safety reasons from situations requiring compensation in the event of cancellations or delays. Payouts are precluded only as a result of "extraordinary circumstances," such as weather or political instability.
"This document, along with the previous declarations and behaviour since the beginning of the pandemic, shows that Air Canada's priority is clearly to try to limit the costs of the flight cancellations instead of providing good service to its clients," Sylvie De Bellefeuille, a lawyer with Quebec-based advocacy group Option consommateurs, said after reviewing a copy of the directive.
She said Air Canada aims to deter passengers from requesting compensation in the first place. "This tactic does not, in our opinion, demonstrate that the company cares about its customers."
Air Canada disagrees with that characterization.
"Air Canada had and continues to have more employees proportionate to its flying schedule when compared prior to the pandemic," the company said in an emailed statement, indicating it had done everything it could to prepare for operational hiccups.
"Air Canada follows all public health directives as part of its safety culture, and during the Omicron wave last winter that affected some crew availability, we revised our policy to better assist customers in their travels with enhanced levels of customer care for flight cancellations related to crew contending with COVID."
John Gradek, head of McGill University's aviation management program, said the transportation agency is partly responsible for the "debacle" because it established looser rules than those in Europe and the United States.
"Carriers have been making strong efforts to point fingers and claim delays are outside of their control to reduce liability," he said in an email.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Aug. 7, 2022.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Chants of 'shame on you' greet guests arriving for the annual White House correspondents' dinner
An election-year roast of U.S. President Joe Biden before journalists, celebrities and politicians at the annual White House correspondents' dinner Saturday.
What is a 'halal mortgage'? Does it make housing more accessible?
The 2024 federal budget announced on April 16 included plans to introduce “halal mortgages” as a way to increase access to home ownership.
Here's where Canadians are living abroad: report
A recent report sheds light on Canadians living abroad--estimated at around four million people in 2016—and the public policies that impact them.
Deadly six-vehicle crash on Highway 400 sparked by road rage incident
One person was killed in a six-vehicle crash on Highway 400 in Innisfil Friday evening.
Opinion I just don't get Taylor Swift
It's one thing to say you like Taylor Swift and her music, but don't blame CNN's AJ Willingham's when she says she just 'doesn't get' the global phenomenon.
Invasive and toxic hammerhead worms make themselves at home in Ontario
Ontario is now home to an invasive and toxic worm species that can grow up to three feet long and can be dangerous to small animals and pets.
Harvey Weinstein hospitalized after return to New York from upstate prison
Harvey Weinstein’s lawyer said Saturday that the onetime movie mogul has been hospitalized for a battery of tests after his return to New York City following an appeals court ruling nullifying his 2020 rape conviction.
'We are declaring our readiness': No decision made yet as Poland declares it's ready to host nuclear weapons
Polish President Andrzej Duda says while no decision has been made around whether Poland will host nuclear weapons as part of an expansion of the NATO alliance’s nuclear sharing program, his country is willing and prepared to do so.
Central Alberta queer groups react to request from Red Deer-South to reinstate Jennifer Johnson to UCP caucus
A number of LGBQT+2s groups in Central Alberta are pushing back against a request from the Red Deer South UCP constituency to reinstate MLA Jennifer Johnson into the UCP caucus.