Deterrent or discrimination? Quebec defends police power to make random traffic stops
The power of police to randomly pull over drivers remains an important tool for deterring dangerous behaviour on the road, a Quebec government lawyer argued Wednesday during a constitutional challenge to traffic stops.
Michel Deom told Superior Court Justice Michel Yergeau that the problem isn't the power itself but its abuse by some police officers.
Deom delivered his closing arguments in a case brought by a Black Montreal resident and the Canadian Civil Liberties Association, who say random police stops violate equality rights guaranteed under the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
"The problem is the behaviour of police officers who overstep their powers," Deom said, adding that it's up to police agencies and watchdog organizations, like the police ethics board, to fight racial profiling by officers.
Joseph-Christopher Luamba, a Black Montreal resident who said he was stopped by police nearly a dozen times without reason, and the civil rights group are challenging the power of Canadian police to stop drivers without a reasonable suspicion an offence was committed. The two plaintiffs, however, are not challenging structured police traffic operations, such as drunk-driving checkpoints.
Bruce W. Johnston, the lawyer for the civil liberties association, argued that allowing police to make random traffic stops opens the door to the arbitrary and discriminatory use of state power.
"This power is not used randomly, but rather in a manner that is discriminatory and highly prejudicial to Black and racialized people, particularly Black men," Johnston and his colleague Lex Gill wrote in a summary of their oral arguments.
On Monday, Johnston told the court that police witnesses called by the government testified that racial profiling doesn't help police work, which he said indicates the power isn't needed. On Tuesday, he said, "When we know that this leads to a systemic violation of the rights of a group, we can't close our eyes and say 'continue to use recourses that don't work."'
The Canadian Civil Liberties Association says that since random police stops disproportionately target Black drivers -- particularly Black men -- the argument that the stops are a reasonable limit on mobility rights should be reconsidered.
If Yergeau sides with the civil liberties group, he'll have to overturn a 1990 Supreme Court decision. In that case, the court ruled that police were justified when they issued a summons to an Ontario driver who had been stopped randomly and who had been driving with a suspended licence.
The high court ruled that random stops are the only way to determine whether drivers are properly licensed, whether a vehicle's seatbelts work and whether a driver is impaired.
"In my view the random stop is rationally connected and carefully designed to achieve safety on the highways," Justice Peter Cory wrote for the majority. Cory added that there must be a "real element of risk of detection" for drivers who get behind the wheel without a licence.
"Random stops supply the only effective deterrent," he wrote.
The Supreme Court found that police powers during random stops were appropriately limited to verifications related to road safety, such as asking for a driver's licence and proof of insurance, and that while police officers could take further steps if they have reasonable grounds, any abuses can be corrected by the courts.
Deom, who entered no new evidence about the dissuasive effect of random police stops, said it was the plaintiff's responsibility to prove that the Supreme Court's ruling on deterrence should be overruled.
"We still have people who continue to drive when they are prohibited," he said. "We still have people who drive when they don't have a driver's licence. The problem hasn't disappeared; therefore, the logic of the court, that it takes a system of verification and enforcement to ensure compliance … remains intact."
Several police officers testified during the trial about the steps Quebec police forces are taking to fight racial profiling and increase diversity in their ranks.
At times, Yergeau challenged Deom about how long that will take.
He said it's clear that a segment of the population is targeted by police and that the testimony heard by the court -- which included 11 Black people who had been the subject of random stops -- was not anecdotal.
"How many generations will it take to ensure that the rights guaranteed by the Charter to Black people are respected while they're driving?" the judge asked.
The trial, which began May 30, is scheduled to end Thursday after the final day of closing arguments.
-- This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 6, 2022.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
What is whooping cough and should Canadians be concerned as Europe declares outbreak?
There is currently a whooping cough epidemic in Europe, with 10 times as many cases compared to the previous two years. While an outbreak has not been declared nationwide in Canada, whooping cough is regularly detected in the country.
Ontario Provincial Police arrest 64 suspects in child sexual exploitation investigation
Ontario Provincial Police say 64 suspects are facing a combined 348 charges in connection with a series of child sexual exploitation investigations that spanned the province.
AstraZeneca says it will withdraw COVID-19 vaccine globally as demand dips
AstraZeneca said on Tuesday it had initiated the worldwide withdrawal of its COVID-19 vaccine due to a 'surplus of available updated vaccines' since the pandemic.
'Summer of discontent': Federal unions vow to fight new 3-day a week office mandate
Federal unions are launching legal challenges and encouraging public sector workers to file "tens of thousands" of grievances over the new mandate requiring federal workers to return to the office at least three days a week in the fall.
Watch fighter jet pilots pummel fake enemy ship off coast of Philippines
The United States and Philippines held annual joint-training drills just off the Southeast Asian nation’s western coast on Wednesday. Military forces sunk a 'mock' enemy warship – the BRP Lake Caliraya, which was a decommissioned tanker made in China.
'Ozempic babies': Reports of surprise pregnancies raise new questions about weight loss drugs
Numerous women have shared stories of 'Ozempic babies' on social media. But the joy some experience in discovering pregnancies may come with anxiety about the unknowns.
OPINION What King Charles' schedule being too 'full' to accommodate son suggests
Prince Harry, the Duke of Sussex, has made headlines with his recent arrival in the U.K., this time to celebrate all things Invictus. But upon the prince landing in the U.K., we have already had confirmation that King Charles III won't have time to see his youngest son during his brief visit.
'I killed four people': Trial hears video evidence of Jeremy Skibicki at Winnipeg trial
“I killed four people,” alleged serial killer Jeremy Skibicki told two homicide detectives during a recorded interview played as evidence in his trial Wednesday.
Seafood, eat food: Calgary Stampede releases Midway menu
The Calgary Stampede has released its menu of sweet, salty and spicy treats available on the Midway for the Greatest Outdoor Show on Earth.