Judge worries amendment to Quebec language law will cause 'undue delays' for English trials
A Quebec judge overseeing the trial of a person accused of killing a cyclist with their car has raised concerns that an amendment to the province's language charter could cause "undue delays" for trials held in English.
Court of Quebec Justice Dennis Galiatsatos wrote in a 17-page ruling that he is worried about an amendment coming into force next month that requires a French translation of any written judgment in English "immediately and without delay."
He has asked the attorneys general of Quebec and Canada to formally weigh in on the matter ahead of the start of the trial of Christine Pryde, who is charged with dangerous driving, impaired driving and criminal negligence, causing the death of cyclist Irene Dehem.
Pryde was charged after a May 18, 2021, collision on L'Anse-a-l'Orme Road on Montreal's West Island and elected to have her trial in English, which is a right under the Criminal Code.
Justice Galiatsatos wrote that the significant trial would certainly end with a written judgment.
At issue is the translation requirement under a provision of the French-language charter, which was amended on June 1, 2022.
The amendment will take effect on June 1, 2024, two days after the trial is scheduled to begin.
"This would imply that Mrs. Pryde, the Crown and Irene Dehem's family will all have to wait several additional weeks or months (the latter being more likely than the former) to receive the final judgment, even though it will be ready long before that, sitting on a shelf while we await a translation by the court services, which will then need to be reviewed, corrected and approved," the judge wrote in his ruling on Wednesday.
Her defence lawyer has argued that the new requirement is "unfair and highly problematic."
The defence is not challenging the constitutionality of the law but instead informed the court last week that it intends to file a motion for a stay of proceedings due to unreasonable delay, given the trial's direction.
The Supreme Court's landmark Jordan ruling in 2016 set strict limits on how long trials must be completed before they violate a person's Charter right to a speedy trial.
In provincial trials, such as Pryde's, the limit is 18 months, whereas the limit for cases before the Superior Court is 30 months.
Last week, the judge reached out to the attorneys general of Quebec and Canada to raise the constitutional question.
The former said at a case-management hearing that it takes issue with the fact that the judge—and not the interested parties—raised the issue on his own initiative and argued that the question was "imprecise and incomplete," according to the ruling.
The Attorney General of Canada agreed that the judge should not have been the one to raise the question and argued that it was a non-issue.
The judge has disagreed with their feedback so far.
"To be abundantly clear, the amendment impacts how and when a judgment may be rendered by a criminal division provincial court judge at the end of a trial. This is no collateral detail. It is as basic as it gets," the judge wrote.
"It goes to one of the judge's core functions, exercised almost weekly. This is far from a purely intellectual exercise being raised out of caprice or boredom. With great respect, it is surprising that the Quebec Attorney General's office objects to the judge raising the issue. It is akin to opening a shoe store and then recoiling at the fact that a customer would dare discuss how shoelaces are tied."
CTV News reached out to Quebec Justice Minister Simon Jolin-Barrette and Minister of the French Language Jean-François Roberge to comment on the legal matter, but their offices did not immediately respond on Thursday.
Justice Galiatsatos said the issue has vast implications for accused people who want to be tried in English in Quebec and has asked both attorneys general to provide written submissions to the court by May 14.
If an accused person files a Jordan motion every time translation causes a delay, "this would have the effect of derailing every English trial in the province," according to the judge. "It would be antithetical to the sound allocation of judicial resources."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Iran President Ebrahim Raisi still missing after helicopter accident in mountains
A helicopter carrying Iranian President Ebrahim Raisi, the country's foreign minister and other officials apparently crashed in the mountainous northwest reaches of Iran on Sunday, sparking a massive rescue operation in a fog-shrouded forest as the public was urged to pray.
What do we know so far about the mysterious crash of the helicopter carrying Iran's president?
The apparent crash of a helicopter carrying Iran's president and foreign minister on Sunday sent shock waves around the region.
'A horrible way to start the summer': 3 killed in serious boat crash on lake north of Kingston, Ont.
Three people were killed and five others were injured Saturday night following a boat crash on the Buck Bay area of Bobs Lake, north of Kingston, Ont., the Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) said.
Walmart, Costco refusing to sign grocery code of conduct 'untenable': industry minister
Industry Minister Francois-Philippe Champagne says it's 'untenable' for 'smaller players' like Walmart and Costco to delay signing on to the government- and industry-led grocery code of conduct, now that industry giant Loblaw has agreed to do so.
Ottawa driver who appeared to be racing another vehicle on Highway 416 facing charges
The Ontario Provincial Police (OPP) says an Ottawa driver is facing charges after being caught going 187 km/h on Highway 416.
Ex-partner charged with first-degree murder after 55-year-old woman killed in Montreal
Less than 24 hours after Montreal's 12th homicide investigation began, Montreal police confirmed that a 55-year-old woman's death in St. Michel is the island's 13th homicide. The woman's ex-spouse has been charged with first-degree murder.
VIDEO Born without front legs, this dog has been inspiring the world for 3 years: Dresden farm owner
A sanctuary dedicated to animals with disabilities is celebrating the third birthday of one of its most popular residents.
Canadian immigration asks medical worker fleeing Gaza if he treated Hamas fighters
Lawyers are questioning Canada’s approach to screening visa applications for people in Gaza with extended family in Canada after one applicant, a medical worker, was asked whether he had treated members of Hamas.
Diddy admits beating ex-girlfriend Cassie, says he's sorry, calls his actions 'inexcusable'
Sean 'Diddy' Combs admitted Sunday that he beat his ex-girlfriend in a hotel hallway in 2016 after CNN released video of the attack, saying in a video apology he was 'truly sorry' and his actions were 'inexcusable.'