'In jail': Teenagers spent 10 days in windowless rooms in Quebec group homes over COVID-19 exposure
Teenagers living in group homes in Laval were confined to windowless rooms for 10 straight days this month, in the name of COVID-19 control – though they didn’t have COVID-19.
The rule, in place for two weeks, was written specifically for youth group homes and was also applied to much younger children, social workers said.
“It's like if she’s been in jail,” said one mother about her 15-year-old daughter, who lives in a group home because she was self-mutilating and running away.
At her daughter's facility, the girls are exceptionally vulnerable and many have serious mental health problems. They only had a potential exposure to the virus, but nevertheless were kept in confinement around the clock, similar to boys in another windowless unit and another home for kids as young as six.
The idea that this kind of measure was used in Quebec youth group homes in the name of children’s health makes her furious, said the mother, Nathalie.
“I'm going to lock you in a room with no window for 10 days. Tell me how you feel,” she said.
In the beginning, “I put her there to protect her,” she said of her daughter's facility.
CTV has chosen not to publish Nathalie’s last name in order to protect the privacy of her daughter, Sabrina.
Laval public health said in a statement that staff at Sabrina's facility, Notre-Dame-de-Laval, and others were following Quebec health ministry rules when they put youth into isolation, and the ministry confirmed this.
After only two weeks, the ministry backtracked on the rule, making sure the province’s youth homes all got a call to tell them verbally to ease up even before authorities had time to rewrite the formal directive.
But a lot of damage was done, said Nathalie.
In fact, Sabrina spent a total of 18 days since Christmastime in her tiny room at Notre-Dame-de-Laval, said Nathalie.
The teenager lives at her unit in the home with about a dozen other girls, the youngest of whom is about 14, though the home can be open to girls as young as 13.
During their repeated lockdowns over the holidays, the girls’ bedroom doors weren’t actually locked—unless they tried to leave them, in which case they could be locked in, Nathalie said.
Staff brought them plates of food to their rooms and escorted them on bathroom breaks. The girls had no phones or laptops, but the staff gave them portable DVD players to pass the time on their beds.
Sabrina was given 10 minutes a day to call her mother, keeping her up to date on the tests she had taken (four in total over the 10 days, all negative) and the rules of the lockdown.
Nathalie said she was perhaps most disturbed by the window issue—she has seen the inside of the unit and knows that the bedrooms get no natural light.
“There's no f**** window in the room,” she said. “My daughter was like, ‘Maman, during the day, I'm always tired, and at four in the morning I'm doing gymnastics in my bed,’” she recalled.
She also knows that sometimes, “there's girls who are there because they attempt suicide,” she said.
PHYSICAL OUTBURSTS, SPITTING
Two social workers who work in Laval said that Notre-Dame-de-Laval wasn't the only home that had to put kids in their rooms during that period -- nor is it the only one without windows.
A unit for boys at the Centre Cartier facility had a similar experience, with the boys put in windowless rooms, and there's also a separate home for children aged six to 12 that was expected to abide by a similar regime.
There weren't many cases of the virus at the group homes, but there were many cases of isolation, the two workers said.
They described dramatic effects on the kids, with some going into physical frenzies that required security staff to hold them down.
Some of the confined youth would "yell, throw punches, try to hurt other people," said social worker Natacha Pelchat, who visits some of the group homes.
A particular concern was a home for children aged six to 12, said her coworker, Pierre-Luc Carrier.
"We have problems with this unit because [the children] need to wear the mask if they want to go out of their rooms," he said. But often the young children refuse.
"Those who don't want to wear the mask, they're in their room, they're spitting at the staff," he said.
"The older ones, they understand more, but the kids six to 12, that's what the staff are telling us -- they don't understand why."
It's unclear if there was a similar spate of lockdowns in group homes in other parts of the province, outside of Laval.
Pelchat and Carrier only work in Laval so they couldn't say. A union that represents this kind of youth social worker, the APTSQ, told CTV News that it hasn’t yet been able to confirm whether other regions had as many lockdowns.
Quebec's commission meant to protect human rights and youth rights told CTV News this week it hasn't yet looked into the situation. A spokesperson said that after checking with staff, "it appears that the Commission has not analyzed or taken a position on this particular issue."
A spokesperson for Batshaw, the youth protection agency run out of the Centre-West health authority in Montreal, referred questions to the ministry of health, which was responsible for the directive.
The 10-day isolation rule arrived from the ministry on Dec. 30, at the height of Quebec’s Omicron wave.
It said that youth living in group homes who should be considered in a “warm zone” must be separated from the group for 10 days. That “warm zone” includes young people with a possible exposure, but no symptoms.
It was ultimately the social workers, disturbed by what they were seeing, who convinced the ministry to do an about-face on Jan. 13. That day, the Laval social workers held a meeting with the local health authority to draw their attention to the urgency of the situation.
The health ministry responded, sparking a flurry of calls to group homes across the province telling them to call off the 10-day rule.
‘WE JUST LOST ALL THIS NOW’
Nathalie was frantically trying to get answers, becoming increasingly worried during Sabrina’s daily phone calls.
“After seven days, I was like, starting to scream… I was getting really mad,” Nathalie said.
She repeatedly called the home’s staff. In the last three days of the isolation, they told her they’d changed the rules: girls would now only spend 23 hours in their rooms per day, and each could spend an hour sitting alone on a balcony, or in the group kitchen, one by one at allotted times.
Indoors, Sabrina grew sick of movies. Sitting on the balcony, she did “nothing,” said her mother. “She looked at squirrels.”
She has sometimes tried to feed the squirrels—she loves animals—but “gets in trouble” for that, said Nathalie.
“I don’t understand,” said her mother.
In a statement, the Laval health district said that while it was following provincial orders, its staff made efforts to ease the “impact… on [the girls’] psychological health.”
Aside from the DVD players, staff members offered to go into the rooms in full protective gear to play a game, such as a board game. They “cooked brunch meals, or home-cooked meals just for them,” including extra treats, said a spokesperson.
The girls got extra time to call home and were offered unlimited time outdoors, in the yard, as long as staff was available, the spokesperson said.
Nathalie said that her daughter played a game of bingo once—with all the girls wearing masks in their rooms and yelling back and forth through the hallway.
She didn’t get any extra phone time and wasn’t offered time in the courtyard, Nathalie said.
Even more worryingly, by the time she was offered the chance to leave her room for an hour a day, she’d lost a lot of interest in doing so, said Nathalie.
“We just lost a lot of progress,” she said.
Sabrina has been living at the home for two years, after coming from another group home.
While her family placed her in the first home voluntarily, the department of youth protection eventually became involved in her file, Nathalie said. All parties agreed to move her to the Laval home—the only one where staff can lock the doors, for the security of girls like her, since she was running away.
Now that Youth Protection is involved, there must be a longer process to decide if she can return home permanently—she can’t just leave, except for overnight visits, which normally happen every weekend and on holidays.
She was doing well, said Nathalie. But after the last month, it seems her development has gone backwards.
When she first arrived at the home she refused to talk to the other girls, or sometimes to leave her room at all.
“After a while she was going out, she was eating with the group, she was doing activities. She was doing everything,” Nathalie said.
She stopped trying to run away and her family has been trying hard to keep her in school.
“And now she's been locked so many times in the room then we just lost all this now,” Nathalie said.
After the lockdown ended last week, it was like her daughter didn’t rejoin the home.
“She doesn't want to go out, like for activities, or sometimes even doesn't want to go out to eat, so she’s just eating by herself in the room,” Nathalie said.
What also infuriated her mother is that while the home was following bureaucratic orders, those orders made no sense given the home’s setup, Nathalie said. Each bedroom does have windows in the door, but these windows have no glass in them—air can pass freely in and out.
During the 10-day lockdown, the girls had to keep curtains over these glassless windows, their only exterior view, “to keep out the COVID,” Nathalie said. If they didn’t keep the curtains closed, they would face “consequences,” mainly wearing masks inside their rooms.
No health authority provided an answer on the logic around this.
A POLICY ABOUT-FACE
When asked about the windowless rooms, the CISSS Laval said it’s trying to get better conditions at the group homes and has a project in the works to modernize that particular centre.
The CISSS “is aware that the units at the [centre] are dilapidated,” the spokesperson wrote.
Two years ago, it wrote a brief to the Special Commission on Children's Rights and Youth Protection, known as the "Laurent Commission," to “advocate for environments that are inviting and have the feeling of security offered by a home conducive to the development of children."
When the Ministry of Health was asked if it had considered the different infrastructure of Quebec’s group homes when it wrote its original directive—for example, whether some children would be kept in windowless rooms—it didn’t respond to that question.
A week after its new verbal directions, the ministry released a written update this Friday, formalizing the new rules.
It has changed the rules to consider youth group homes to be primarily living environments rather than care environments more akin to hospitals, explained spokesperson Robert Maranda.
“At the time of the events, the Youth Centres were subject to the instructions relating to care settings and the related isolation instructions,” wrote Maranda.
Now, however, they’re seen as living environments where the inhabitants can all be considered one “bubble,” he wrote.
The CISSS Laval also wrote that “with the return to school, young people living in the same living unit will now be considered as a residential bubble in which the health measures in force in society will be applied.”
Maranda said the new directive tries to weigh the health drawbacks of extended isolation versus the health benefits of possibly preventing COVID-19.
It “takes into consideration the benefits of preventing the psychosocial deconditioning of young people compared to the possible consequences of being infected with COVID-19,” he wrote.
For Nathalie, however, the health tradeoffs were already clear, and the effect on the girls who already lived through the experience can’t necessarily be so easily fixed -- and those who care for them should have known that, she said.
“I don’t know [all] the girls, I don’t know their problems," she said, "but they’re all there for a reason."
Montreal Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Students trapped inside a classroom with a gunman repeatedly called 911 during this week's attack on a Texas elementary school, including one who pleaded, 'Please send the police now,' as nearly 20 officers waited in the hallway for more than 45 minutes, authorities said Friday.
As Johnny Depp's high-profile libel lawsuit against ex-wife Amber Heard wound down, Heard took her final opportunity on the stand to comment on the hate and backlash she’s endured online during the trial.
A new report says Ottawa, Vancouver and Toronto rank among the top 20 cities around the world when it comes to work-life balance.
Federal Public Safety Minister Marco Mendicino will table new firearms legislation on Monday, according to his colleague Justice Minister David Lametti. In an interview with CTV's Question Period that will air on Sunday, Lametti pointed to the advance notice given to the House of Commons, and confirmed the plan is to see the new bill unveiled shortly after MPs return to the Commons on May 30.
An 11-year-old survivor of the Robb Elementary School massacre in Uvalde, Texas, feared the gunman would come back for her so she smeared herself in her friend's blood and played dead.
For 70 years, Andre Hissink has held a grudge against the Dutch government, but this week, the 102-year-old Second World War veteran’s persistence paid off – the Dutch king granted his wish for a rare dual citizenship.
Canada has tapped into its own strategic stockpile of emergency medical supplies -- stored for a national emergency -- to help Ukraine. It has donated over 375,000 items of medical equipment and medicines from Canada's strategic stockpile since the invasion by Russia began.
Takotsubo cardiomyopathy, more commonly known as 'broken heart syndrome' or stress-induced cardiomyopathy, is an actual medical condition triggered by severe emotional or physical stress and is different from a heart attack.
After a six-week trial in which Johnny Depp and Amber Heard tore into each other over the nasty details of their short marriage, both sides told a jury the exact same thing Friday -- they want their lives back.
Police have released a video showing the arrest of two suspects who allegedly stole a Mercedes – the latest in a string of armed vehicle thefts that has prompted police services in the Greater Toronto Area to create a carjacking task force.
Toronto Pearson International is warning travellers and Mississauga residents they may notice unusual activity at the airport this weekend.
New video has emerged showing the moment a tornado touched down in Uxbridge, Ont. over the weekend, ripping the roof off a local brewery.
A lawyer for families of victims killed in the Nova Scotia mass shooting says an 18-hour delay in finding five bodies of those murdered is a sign of "deficient" policing.
The RCMP is trying to determine who was driving a car near the scene of a double-homicide in Dieppe, N.B., in September 2019.
'We just want to stay': N.S. family struggling to find affordable home may be forced to leave the province
A Nova Scotia family may be forced to leave the province due to the lack of affordable housing units on the market today.
The London Police Service is requesting the public’s help with locating a person of interest after a gun was fired on Richmond Row in the early morning hours of Friday.
A London man is facing impaired-related charges after a vehicle he was driving collided with a gravel truck on Wednesday morning, according to police.
Pat Clifford is the engine that keeps the St. Vincent de Paul Society in Goderich, Ont. running — and it’s for those reasons the soon-to-be 75-year-old has earned the Sovereign’s Medal for Volunteers.
Canadian Institute of Mining, Metallurgy and Petroleum (CIM) has honoured two people from Sudbury for their rescue efforts during last year's rescue at Totten Mine.
A 54-year-old man is facing several charges in Sudbury, including sexual assault, following an investigation triggered by reports someone was trying to traffic a victim under the age of 16.
There’s an increased police presence around four Toronto schools this morning after a 27-year-old man walking the nearby streets with an air rifle was shot dead by police on Thursday.
Temperatures are rising in Calgary and workers who help make sure pets are kept safe from harm say residents need to be aware of the risks that come with the change of seasons.
Alberta Parks has closed a section of Fish Creek Provincial Park in the city's southeast after aggressive coyotes attacked a dog and its owner.
Calgary Flames fans are still coming to terms with a playoff series loss to the Edmonton Oilers Thursday night in a game that saw both controversy and heartbreak following a Connor McDavid overtime goal.
A man, who was a referee at high school volleyball games in Guelph for more than 30 years, is facing sex assault-related charges.
The Region of Waterloo says there's a high safety risk at a Kitchener encampment and they are working with residents to prepare them for their eventual move.
The Queen Victoria statue in downtown Kitchener is once again clean after it was splashed with red paint earlier this week.
Vancouver police are investigating a double stabbing they say happened at an apartment building in Kitsilano Friday morning.
Mounties say a suspicious device found on the side of a road in West Kelowna Thursday was, in fact, an explosive.
Multiple drivers ran over a firefighting hose in South Vancouver on Friday, impacting an already tense effort to douse the flames at a two-alarm house fire.
A 19-year-old man is in police custody after a shooting near Rogers Place after an Edmonton Oilers viewing party ended Thursday evening.
Ground was officially broken on Edmonton's Valley Line West LRT route on Friday.
The province officially started or resumed work on 300 highway projects Friday – worth a total of $1.4 billion – but a shortage of workers and the high cost of materials will have an impact.
Windsor police are asking for the public’s help identify a driver who fled after a rollover crash.
'Just do Mable things': Father of 18-year-old Pain Court crash victim shares memories of his daughter
It’s been a long and sorrow-filled week for the extended families of Mable Baker, an 18-year-old Chatham-Kent woman who was involved in a fatal car crash last weekend.
A local musician will be back on stage for the 16th annual 24-Hour Drum Marathon.
Premiers from western Canada met to discuss healthcare in their first face-to-face meeting in more than two years in Regina on Friday at the 2022 Western Premiers' Conference.
A Regina family facing homelessness will not be evicted from their government-owned rental unit after it was discovered they owed more than $1,000 in back rent.
An alleged mail theft and identity fraud has resulted in more than 100 charges for a 42-year-old Edmonton man, according to the Regina Police Service (RPS).
As of Friday evening, 26,000 Hydro Ottawa customers remain without power in all neighbourhoods of the city.
The principal of a French Catholic high school in Orleans is leaving the school this week, two weeks after students said a dress code enforcement "blitz" left them feeling degraded and humiliated.
Ottawa Public Health is reporting 15 Ottawa residents in hospital because of an active COVID-19 infection on Friday, down from 17 on Thursday.
'We will have to deal with the issues': Saskatoon condo residents at odds with city over public washroom plan
Outcry over the planned location of public washrooms caused Tuesday's city council meeting to stretch late into the evening.
Saskatchewan Roughriders rookie Nelson Lokombo is ready to return to the football field after missing the entire 2021 season with an achilles injury.
A Saskatchewan woman’s granddaughter is being recognized for helping save her life and minimizing the effects of stroke after she called 911.