Former Amazon warehouse worker sounds alarm ahead of Prime Day
Amazon's annual Prime Day event will be held on July 16 and 17, but behind the deals lie health and security concerns for warehouse and delivery workers, according to one former employee.
Mostafa Henaway knows all too well the health risks faced by Amazon workers. Three years ago, Henaway penned an article in The Breach where he detailed how he infiltrated Amazon's Laval warehouse and what he learned from the experience.
Henaway is now a community organizer with the Immigrant Workers Centre in Montreal, an organization that defends the rights of immigrants in their workplaces. He is also a PhD candidate at Concordia University focusing on working conditions in e-commerce warehouses.
According to his experience and testimonies from workers during Amazon Prime Day, warehouse and delivery staff work 50 hours a week, have less access to personal time off, and must take on mandatory overtime.
"Workers are walking 20 kilometres a shift, also [during] a moment of extreme heat. Across [Amazon]'s workforce, there is no room to say, 'It's 40 degrees, I'm going to take an extra five minutes to drink that water.'"
Amazon denied this allegation.
Henaway noted how essential the services of warehouse and delivery workers are.
"We all appreciate getting that package the next day, but behind that, it's not actually Amazon's technology," he said. "In Quebec, it's over 2,000 workers, who are 24 hours a day, seven days a week, making sure that people get what they need, on time and delivered to their doorstep, and those workers should be respected."
Agrait said that employees may be asked to work overtime during times of high demand.
"But, they’ll never be asked to work more than 10 hours per day and no more than 50 hours in a week - which is in compliance with Canadian labour laws," she said.
She added that they aim to provide several days notice when overtime is necessary, and that it is "common-practice in the retail industry during high volume events."
High levels of surveillance
Pressure also comes in the form of quotas, said Henaway.
"Workers are having to fulfill over 200 packages per hour," he said. "Even though Amazon declares to the public that they don't have quotas, workers go to their meetings when they start their shift, they are told there are no quotas, but then people are punished for not making quotas. They're given automated warnings, they're disciplined."
When asked for comments about quotas, Amazon spokesperson Barbara Agrait said: “At Amazon, employees’ safety is our top priority and at the core of everything we do. Amazon does not have fixed quotas at our facilities. Instead, we assess performance based on safe and achievable expectations and take into account time and tenure, peer performance, and adherence to safe work practices. Less than 0.5 per cent of frontline employees are separated from the company due to performance. We’re constantly listening to and engaging with our employees and providing them with the resources they need to be successful.”
Henaway said workers are heavily monitored. According to him, the number and length of bathroom breaks are monitored, and supervisors check the bathrooms "constantly."
Agrait said employees are free to take informal breaks throughout their shifts to use the restroom, get water, or talk to a manager or HR, in addition to their regularly scheduled breaks. She added that they "immediately investigate" concerns around managers asking employees to prioritize productivity over safety.
Artificial intelligence cameras are also used to operate Amazon's fulfillment centres and monitor employees' productivity, said Henaway.
"At the same time, workers wear devices that tell them what their next task is, or they have a monitoring station, which tells them [how long they have] to fulfill that package," said Henaway. "On top of this, you have all the supervisors monitoring that data. So, that level of, of stress is immense."
Agrait said they use technology in their facilities to ensure employees' safety and security of our employees. She added it helps keep track of inventory in their facilities.
"It would be irresponsible if we didn’t," she said.
Agrait said Amazon doesn’t use camera technology in their warehouses to monitor employees and directed workers to their managers for more information.
Henaway noted that the level of surveillance coupled with high productivity standards faced by Amazon workers often lead to mental health risks and burnouts.
He also pointed to a study showed that Amazon has a 150 per cent turnover rate annually. "That is not a sign of a good employer, if the fact is that your entire workforce is changing in less than a year."
Amazon said the draft documents cited in the study had not been fully vetted or approved.
Immigrant workers disproportionately affected
The rhythm and repetition linked to the pace of work heighten health and safety risks, said Henaway. He added that workers, especially immigrant workers, aren't well equipped and informed about their resources in the event of an injury.
"We hear from workers and what we see at the Immigrant Workers Centre, is that a lot of times when workers are injured, they're not given the right information," said Henaway.
Agrait said Amazon has allocated more than $750 million this year towards safety enhancements, programs, and technologies.
“Our safety performance has continued to improve, and we’re proud of our progress which includes a 30 per cent reduction in recordable incidents across our worldwide network since 2019,” Agrait wrote in the statement.
She said that all employees go through safety training on Day 1 and receive additional training based on their role in the warehouse.
“While we do experience higher order volumes during busy shopping periods, our commitment to safety doesn’t change: Safety is our top priority every single day, and we’re constantly working to ensure employees have safe, comfortable, and inclusive workplaces,” wrote Agrait.
Henaway said that, for many immigrant Amazon workers, it is often their first job in the country.
"For them, this job is very important, despite the kind of conditions and the issues that [they] face," said Henaway. "And so a lot of workers bear it for as long as they can."
According to him, there is a two-tiered workforce at Amazon, divided into blue and white badges, or temporary and permanent workers. He explained workers start off as white badges, and stay in the hopes of obtaining a blue badge, or permanent employment.
He added that immigrant workers are often scared to speak up.
"There's a lot of pressure when workers are organizing to stand up for their basic rights," said Henaway. "They feel that this could affect their immigration, when actually it has nothing to do with one or the other, or their fundamental rights regardless of their immigration status."
The workers at Amazon’s Laval’s warehouse were granted the right to unionize last May. A month later, Amazon challenged the certification of a union, as it said the process was unlawful because it involved signing union cards instead of voting in a secret ballot. The company filed for the union’s certificate to be revoked entirely.
American Senate review
A report released Tuesday by Sen. Bernie Sanders said Amazon Prime Day is a "major cause of injuries" for warehouse workers across the United States.
The report is based on information from a year-long investigation into Amazon's safety practices by the Senate, interviews with more than 100 current and former workers, as well as internal company data from 2019 and 2020. It said the highest weekly injury rates for warehouse workers occured during peak shopping times like the holidays and Prime Day.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Girl, 15, set on fire in assault at Saskatoon high school: police
A 15-year-old girl was set on fire in an assault at Saskatoon's Evan Hardy Collegiate Thursday afternoon, police say.
Liberal national campaign director says he will step down
Embattled Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and his governing Liberals have taken another hit with Jeremy Broadhurst quitting his job as national campaign director for the party.
Father of Georgia school shooting suspect arrested on charges including second-degree murder
The father of the teenager accused of opening fire at a Georgia high school, killing four people and wounding nine, was arrested on various charges including second-degree murder, authorities said Thursday.
Toronto couple pushes for change after dog attacked by pack of coyotes
It started like any other night for Mary and Doug Youngson: a walk at their neighbourhood park with their rescue dogs, Mai Tai and Kahlua. But when the couple looked around, they say a pack of eight coyotes surrounded them, picked Kahlua up and ran off with him.
A Canadian airline is changing its check-in deadline for all flights. Here's why
Travellers will have to check in 15 minutes earlier than usual according to Air Canada's new cutoff time for all flights.
Man dies after surgeon removed wrong organ at Florida hospital, lawyer says
The lawyer of a woman whose husband died at a Florida hospital says the surgeon removed the wrong organ.
Conservative cuts? Party to share platform 'closer to the next election,' Scheer says
Conservative House Leader Andrew Scheer says Canadians will have to wait until 'closer' to the next federal election to learn about the party's platform.
Student convicted of killing classmate in Leduc gets life in prison without parole for 12 years
The man who fatally stabbed a classmate at his Leduc high school in 2021 was sentenced to life in prison with no parole eligibility for 12 years on Thursday.
Murder, aggravated assault charges laid in Vancouver stranger attacks
Charges of murder and aggravated assault in a pair of brutal stranger attacks in downtown Vancouver were approved Thursday, one day after the rush-hour rampage left one man dead and another with a severed hand.