Class-action wants Apple to uphold iPhone water resistance promise to Quebec customers
A Quebec law firm is seeking authorization for a class-action lawsuit against Apple for anyone in the province who has had their iPhone damaged by water.
LPC Avocats argue that Apple advertises its iPhones as "water resistant," but that Apple Store employees "systematically refuse to repair or replace" the devices that came into contact with liquid based on a warranty exclusion for damage caused by getting it wet.
"In short, Apple's iPhones are consistently damaged by liquid contact that Apple advertised and promised that they could withstand," the law firm says. "As such, this class action seeks to have the clause in Apple's warranty excluding liquid contact voided and to obtain damages for all Class Members who were forced to pay any amount to replace or repair their iPhone due to liquid contact (or water damage) that occurred in conditions that Apple advertised and promised the iPhones could withstand."
Lawyer Joey Zukran is leading the case and is representing a 19-year-old CEGEP student who was in Mexico when her phone came into contact with water near a pool.
"It immediately stopped working, her phone was purchased brand new eight months ago," Zukran told CJAD 800 Radio host Elias Makos.
When his client took the phone to the Genius Bar, Zukran said she was told she was excluded due to it coming in contact with water.
"So the warranty says that it does not apply the data liquid contact, which is completely ridiculous when you look at the marketing that Apple uses," said Zukran. "How can you exclude liquid when you advertise that it can fall in a pool and be fine? (...) In the case of my clients, and many people who contact their office, they're not fine. Apple refuses to fix it, and the only remedy is to buy a brand new phone."
The class action seeks to make the "liquid contact" exclusion null and void, reimburse those who paid to have phones fixed and pay $500 to anyone who signs up for the case.
Zukran said that in Quebec, the law states that marketing forms part of a consumer contract and "declarations made by the representative of a company also form part of the contract."
"So you essentially have a contract that says your phone is 'Oops resistant', you can drop it in the pool, and you'll be fine, only to come a few paragraphs later and say liquid contact voids your warranty," he said. "So you have two contradictory clauses in a consumer contract, which, again, according to the law, has to be interpreted in favour of the consumer or the adherent."
It is not the first time Zukran has targeted Apple with a class-action lawsuit for violating Quebec's Consumer Protection Act.
In 2018, Zukran, along with another lawyer, argued that Apple failed to warn consumers of Quebec's legal warranty in the act and the fact that it requires manufacturers to guarantee their products, in this case, the phone's battery, for a reasonable amount of time.
The ruling went against Apple, and the Quebec Court of Appeal upheld the decision in 2021.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
'It looks quite real': Two Ontarians lose money to fake phone scam
About 85 per cent of Canadians have a smartphone and once you have one they’re hard to live without. The latest smartphones can cost as much as $2,000, so if you’re trying to save money, make sure you don’t get caught in a fake smartphone scam.
America reaches Election Day and a stark choice between Trump and Harris
A presidential campaign marked by upheaval and rancor approached its finale on Election Day as Americans decided whether to send Donald Trump back to the White House or elevate Kamala Harris to the Oval Office.
New homeowners find skeleton in attic 15 years after previous occupant disappeared
Homeowners in France have discovered a skeleton in the attic of an outbuilding while undertaking renovation work.
Months after VRBO booking, Taylor Swift fan told home 'not available' during Vancouver concert
A frustrated Taylor Swift fan is speaking out after being pushed from a short-term rental she booked for the upcoming Vancouver leg of the superstar’s Eras Tour.
North Korean troops in Russia are shelled by Ukrainian forces, an official says
North Korean troops recently deployed to help Russia in its war with Ukraine have come under Ukrainian fire, a Kyiv official said Tuesday.
Dutch police arrest a suspect in a botched art heist of Andy Warhol screenprints
Police arrested a 23-year-old man Tuesday on suspicion of involvement in a botched art heist at a gallery in the southern Netherlands targeting four valuable Andy Warhol screenprints.
Tim Hortons parent Restaurant Brands misses sales estimates on muted demand
Restaurant Brands missed estimates for quarterly revenue on Tuesday due to weak demand across key businesses such as Tim Hortons, Burger King and international markets including China and the Middle East.
Canada Post, union, still disagree over weekend delivery following weekend talks
Canada Post and the union representing its workers are commenting on how weekend talks for a new contract went, with the employer calling them less productive than they'd hoped and the union claiming their employer is focused on flexibility to deliver parcels at the lowest possible cost.
A week after Spain's floods, families hold out hope that loved ones are not among the dead
Francisco Murgui went out to try to salvage his motorbike when the water started to rise.