Quebec labour code doesn't infringe rights of casino managers, Supreme Court rules
Excluding front-line supervisors at a Montreal casino from organizing under the Quebec labour-relations regime does not infringe their constitutional rights, the Supreme Court of Canada has ruled.
In a decision Friday, the top court said barring managers from the regime through a provision of the Quebec labour code is not a violation of their Charter guarantee of freedom of association.
Seventy per cent of the operation supervisors assigned to gaming tables at Casino de Montréal were members of an association that filed a petition for certification in 2009.
As part of the petition, the association asked that the exclusion of managerial personnel from the definition of "employee" in the provincial labour code be declared "constitutionally inoperative."
The association, which also represents front-line managers at three other Quebec casinos, successfully argued before a tribunal that the definition infringed the freedom of association guaranteed by the Charter of Rights.
The Quebec Superior Court allowed an application for judicial review from the employer, Société des casinos du Québec, on the basis there were several errors in the administrative ruling.
However, the Quebec Court of Appeal overturned that decision, prompting the employer to take its case to the Supreme Court.
Writing for a majority of the high court, Justice Mahmud Jamal identified the appropriate two part-test for deciding whether legislation infringes the Charter provision guaranteeing freedom of association.
The first step involves determining whether the association's activities fall within the scope of the Charter provision.
Jamal found the association's claims were indeed grounded in the provision, including the right to form a body independent from the employer, to make collective representations to the employer and to have them considered in good faith.
The second step of the test entails determining whether the legislative exclusion substantially interferes with the protected activities of the association's members.
Jamal said the purpose of the exclusion under the provincial labour code was not to interfere with managers' associational rights.
Rather, the intent of excluding managers from the definition of "employee" under the code was to:
- distinguish between management and operations in an organization's hierarchy;
- avoid placing managers in a conflict of interest between their role as representatives of the employer and their role as employees in collective bargaining;
- give employers confidence that managers would represent their interests, while protecting the distinctive common interests of employees.
Jamal said the association had also failed to show that the effect of the legislative exclusion is to substantially interfere with its members' rights to meaningful collective bargaining.
He noted the supervisors managed to group together to form the association, and the Montreal division was voluntarily recognized by the employer as the representative of front-line managers.
In addition, the employer and the Montreal division have successfully concluded a memorandum of understanding providing a framework for collaboration and consultation on working conditions and related issues, he wrote.
Jamal concluded the terms of the memo demonstrate that the association's members "are able to associate and collectively bargain with their employer."
This report by The Canadian Press was first published April 19, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Parents of infant who died in wrong-way crash on Ontario's Hwy. 401 were in same vehicle
Ontario’s Special Investigations Unit has released new details about a wrong-way collision in Whitby on Monday night that claimed the lives of four people.
Three Quebec men from same family father hundreds of children
Three men in Quebec from the same family have fathered more than 600 children.
Jurors in Trump hush money trial hear recording of pivotal call on plan to buy affair story
Jurors in the hush money trial of Donald Trump heard a recording Thursday of him discussing with his then-lawyer and personal fixer a plan to purchase the silence of a Playboy model who has said she had an affair with the former president.
B.C. mayor stripped of budget, barred from committees over Indigenous residential schools book
A British Columbia mayor has been censured by city council – stripping him of his travel and lobbying budgets and removing him from city committees – for allegedly distributing a book that questions the history of Indigenous residential schools in Canada.
New scam targets Canada Carbon Rebate recipients
Fake text message and email campaigns trying to get money and information out of unsuspecting Canadian taxpayers have started circulating, just months after the federal government rebranded the carbon tax rebate the Canada Carbon Rebate.
Universities grapple with the complicated politics of campus encampments
Montreal police are facing pressure to move in and dismantle a pro-Palestinian encampment on McGill University campus on Thursday, as a growing number of universities across this country grapple with the tough decision of how to handle the protests.
Police order B.C. woman who praised Hamas not to protest for 5 months, says her group
A pro-Palestinian activist group says its international co-ordinator, who was arrested in a Vancouver hate-crime investigation, was released with an order not to attend any protests for the next five months.
Conservative MP says Chinese hacking attack targeted his personal email
A Conservative MP is challenging claims by House of Commons administration that a China-backed hacking attempt did not impact any members of Parliament, because the attack was on his personal email.
Loblaw leaders call criticism 'misguided,' say they aren't to blame for high food prices
Loblaw chairman Galen Weston and the company's new CEO are pushing back against critics who blame the grocery giant for soaring food prices, as a month-long boycott of the retailer gets underway.