Montreal school board to ask Supreme Court to hear appeal of Quebec secularism law
The debate over the constitutionality of Quebec's secularism law is poised to go to the Supreme Court of Canada.
On Wednesday evening, the English Montreal School Board (EMSB) voted in favour of asking Canada's top court to rule on Bill 21 after a Feb. 29 Quebec Court of Appeal ruling that upheld the law.
In a unanimous decision, the province's highest court upheld the law that prohibits public sector workers in positions of authority — including teachers, judges and police officers — from wearing religious symbols on the job.
The National Council of Canadian Muslims was one of many groups that had intervenor status in the previous legal challenge of the law.
The ruling was a blow to the EMSB, Quebec's largest English-language public school board, which had previously been exempted from the law after a ruling by the Superior Court of Quebec.
Commissioner Pietro Mercuri said at Wednesday's meeting that the board's vote was an important historical lesson about standing up for fundamental rights.
"History has shown that when governments denied people jobs in positions based on how they look, how they dress due to their faith, it's only a precursor for even worse things to come," he said. "Bill 21 excludes people from obtaining certain jobs in positions based on what they wear according to their faith. Not continuing a fight against Bill 21, Mr. Chairman, in my opinion, is a profound disrespect against previous generations who have fought to protect people who have been marginalized and made to feel unwanted by their government."
During a special board meeting, 12 board members voted in favour of a motion to bring the challenge to the Supreme Court.
One member voted against, one abstained and another was not present.
To help pass the law, Premier François Legault's Coalition Avenir Québec (CAQ) government relied on preemptively using the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms' notwithstanding clause, which shields legislation from most court challenges over violations of fundamental rights.
The Quebec Superior Court had exempted English school boards from certain provisions of the law on the basis that minority language education rights — which aren't covered by the Charter's notwithstanding clause — weren't respected.
However, the three-judge appeal panel rejected that analysis in its February ruling.
Debate over legal costs
According to commissioner Joseph Lalla, the board has already spent $1.3 million to date in legal costs in challenging the law.
Some commissioners raised concerns about the funds being better spent elsewhere in its schools and where the new funds for the upcoming appeal will come from.
He was critical of the board for not reaching out to other school boards to help finance an appeal to Canada's highest court.
"Why would they contribute any money at this point because if we are successful at the Supreme Court they will get all the benefits without costing a single penny for them," Lalla said.
He nevertheless supported the motion, saying "there are times when the EMSB must fight for its value and its rights, which are being encroached upon by the CAQ government."
EMSB Chair Joe Ortona said in February the money spent so far represented a small fraction of the board's $2 billion budget over the last five years.
Julien Feldman also voted yes on the motion on Wednesday.
"I appreciate the debate about the money," he said, "but, frankly, I believe the debate should be about the principles of the matter and the merits of the case."
-- with files from The Canadian Press.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
El Nino weakening doesn't mean cooler temperatures this summer, forecasters say
As Canadians brace themselves for summer temperatures, forecasters say a weakening El Nino cycle doesn’t mean relief from the heat.
BREAKING 15-year-old boy stabbed Thursday in Nepean dies
A 15-year old boy who was critically injured after a stabbing in Nepean on Thursday has died of his injuries, Ottawa's English public school board said Sunday.
Dash cam catches moment suspected drunk driver hits parked car, sends it careening into North Shore flower shop
Police say it’s fortunate no one was injured or killed in a collision at North Vancouver’s Park and Tilford shopping centre Saturday evening that sent one vehicle careening into a flower shop and another into a set of concrete barriers outside a Winners store.
Nylander defends Leafs' core after playoff exit, Toronto again picks up the pieces
The Maple Leafs battled back from a 3-1 series deficit against the Boston Bruins with consecutive 2-1 victories - including one that required extra time - in their first-round playoff series to push the club's Original Six rival to the limit before suffering a devastating Game 7 overtime loss.
Amid climate change warnings, Canadians lukewarm on electric vehicles
Amid scientists' warnings that nations need to transition away from fossil fuels to limit climate change, Canadians are still lukewarm on electric vehicles, according to a study conducted by Nanos Research for CTV News.
Three dead, two hospitalized, following collision in Fredericton: police
Three people have died and two have been hospitalized after a speeding car struck a tree and landed on another vehicle in Fredericton Sunday morning.
Montreal man on the hook for thousands of dollars after a feature on his Tesla caused an accident
A Montreal man is warning Tesla drivers about using the Smart Summon feature after his vehicle hit another in a parking lot.
Madonna's biggest-ever concert transforms Rio's Copacabana beach into a massive dance floor
Madonna put on a free concert on Copacabana beach Saturday night, turning Rio de Janeiro's vast stretch of sand into an enormous dance floor teeming with a multitude of her fans.
Mexican authorities say thieves killed 2 Australians and an American to steal their truck
Thieves killed two Australians and an American on a surfing trip to Mexico in order to steal their truck, particularly because they wanted the tires, authorities said Sunday.