Anti-abortion activists challenge Quebec law forcing demonstrators to keep distance
A Superior Court judge heard final arguments Thursday in a constitutional challenge of a Quebec law that requires protesters to stay 50 metres away from abortion clinics.
The Quebec Life Coalition and other anti-abortion activists took the province to court over the law, which they say violates their rights to freedom of expression and peaceful assembly enshrined in the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
On the other side of the courtroom, lawyers representing the Quebec attorney general and three facilities providing abortions argued the law must stand to protect the rights of women seeking those services.
Introduced in 2016, Section 16 of the Act Respecting Health Services and Social Services states that no person is permitted to demonstrate within 50 metres of a facility providing abortion service in any way that attempts to “dissuade a woman from obtaining such a service or contest or condemn her choice of obtaining or having obtained the service.”
The law also specifies that no demonstrator may “attempt to dissuade a person from providing, or from participating in the provision of, such a service."
Robert E. Reynolds, the lawyer representing the plaintiffs, said the law has prevented demonstrators from engaging in what they call “sidewalk counselling." Georges Buscemi, president of the coalition, said in an interview that “sidewalk counselling" is a peaceful way to propose alternatives to terminating pregnancy and does not block access to the facilities.
Reynolds argued that the law effectively banishes demonstrators from expressing their views in a public space, undermining democratic debate. Therefore, he added, the law should be struck down as "inoperable and unconstitutional."
"The plaintiffs have without a doubt the right to peacefully exercise their right to freedom of expression ... and more specifically on sidewalks in front of buildings where abortions are provided," he said.
However, provincial government lawyers argued the provision in the law was enacted to protect vulnerable women from harassment and intimidation. Before it was introduced, two of the three clinics fighting the challenge — Fémina Medical Clinic and Morgentaler Clinic — had to obtain injunctions against protesters, they noted.
Lawyer Éric Cantin said the limit on protesters' Charter rights is justified and reasonable when balanced against the right of women and staff to enter the facilities without being targeted by protesters attempting to dissuade them from accessing abortion services.
"We're not forbidding all protests. We're not forbidding the spreading of a message," Cantin said, explaining that the demonstrators are free to express their views outside of the buffer zones.
Joséane Chrétien, one of the lawyers representing the three clinics providing abortion services, said that protesters have subjected women and staff to aggressive and violent behaviour.
Chrétien said that at least one of those people has been "attacked," and she alleged that Brian Jenkins, one of the plaintiffs, has followed people and published information about them online.
"He has imposed himself on patients and the people who accompany them. He follows their movements. He puts them in a repertoire and catalogues them. He puts them on his blog," she told the court. “These are not peaceful actions."
Quebec Superior Court Justice Lysane Cree has reserved her decision.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 14, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Canada Post strike: Union 'extremely disappointed' in latest offer, negotiator says
A negotiator for the Canadian Union of Postal Workers (CUPW) says the latest offer from Canada Post to end the ongoing strike shows the carrier is moving in the "opposite direction."
Canada's air force took video of object shot down over Yukon, updated image released
The Canadian military has released more details and an updated image of the unidentified object shot down over Canada's Yukon territory in February 2023.
Invasive species could be hiding in your Christmas decor. Here's how to stop the spread
Make sure to look through your holiday decorations, as Christmas trees, wreaths, and other natural decor can have invasive insects, eggs, and plants that pose a threat to local ecosystems and the economy.
Sask. doctor facing professional charges in circumcision case
A Saskatoon doctor has been accused of unprofessional conduct following a high-cost adult circumcision that included a request for the patient to text unsecured post-op pictures of his genitals.
Notre Dame reopens its doors to Macron and other world leaders in a rare symbol of unity
France's iconic Notre Dame Cathedral is formally reopening its doors on Saturday for the first time since a devastating fire nearly destroyed the 861-year-old landmark in 2019.
'Shameful': Monument honouring fallen soldiers included names of living veterans
Veterans are asking for answers after discovering that two sculptures in Ontario honouring fallen soldiers include the names of many people who are very much alive.
Man arrested after 16-hour standoff with Barrie police seeks to be released from custody
The 43-year-old man taken to hospital in distress following a 16-hour armed standoff with Barrie police last month is seeking bail.
Northern Ontario man sentenced for killing his dog
WARNING: This article contains graphic details of animal abuse which may be upsetting to some readers. A 40-year-old northern Ontario man is avoiding prison after pleading guilty to killing his dog earlier this year.
Calgary company steps up to help grieving family with free furnace after fatal carbon monoxide poisoning
A Calgary furnace company stepped up big time Friday to help a Calgary family grieving the loss of a loved one.