3 men accused in Montreal car theft ring walk free due to court delays
Even though authorities are trying to crack down on car thefts in Montreal, three men accused of operating a luxury car theft ring in the city walked free last month because it took too long for their case to go to trial.
In a ruling handed down by the Court of Quebec, Justice Salvatore Mascia said he "had no choice" but to issue a stay of proceedings against Obeida Borghol, James Rizk and Ali Trad.
The trio was set to go on trial on May 6, 2024, after being charged in 2021 following a month-long investigation by several Montreal police officers.
However, the judge said the time it took for Crown prosecutor to move the case forward through the justice system was unreasonable and violated the accused's Charter right to a speedy trial.
Justice Mascia underlined how "regrettable" his decision was because investigative efforts by Montreal police were wasted.
"Not without concern, car theft has become a scourge throughout the country and particularly in the City of Montreal," he wrote in his Jan. 22 decision.
The ruling comes as the federal government and local police are taking steps to address rising concerns about car theft, particularly in hot spots like Montreal.
The three men were allegedly part of a "simple but structured" car theft operation.
According to the investigator, they would rent high-end vehicles from car rental companies, install a GPS tracking device and make a copy of the key.
Then, when another customer rented the vehicle, the alleged thieves would track its location and steal it, according to the judgment.
The vehicles that were targeted include Jeep Grand Cherokees, Dodge Durangos, Toyota RAV4s and a Hyundai Tucson.
Extensive police work was involved, including several hours of on-the-ground surveillance, collaboration with police in Ontario, at least six warrants to obtain cellphone records and seizing surveillance video footage.
The prosecution relied on two arguments to justify the delay: the case was overly complex and was affected by a backlog of cases due to the pandemic.
However, the judge ruled that "the case was mishandled at the very beginning of the proceedings," and that while the COVID-19 health crisis did have a domino effect on delaying court cases over the years, the Crown failed to make sure this case didn't fall through the cracks.
"The Court is of the opinion that the backlash effect of COVID-19 cannot continue to serve as a blanket exemption justifying the delays in the case at hand," wrote Justice Mascia, adding, "there must come a time when the pandemic can no longer be considered an exceptional circumstance."
Cases must be completed in provincial courts within 18 months, according to the limits established by the Supreme Court of Canada's landmark ruling in 2016, known as the Jordan decision.
When subtracting the length of delay attributed to the defence in the case of Rizk, the court is left with a delay of 1,101 days — more than twice the limit set by the Jordan decision.
The defence delay was calculated at 286 days combined for the other two accused, leaving an overall delay of 815 days, which exceeded the limit by nearly eight months.
Last week, Quebec provincial police said a new mixed police squad recovered 53 stolen vehicles at the Port of Montreal after searching 26 shipping containers.
Officers note that stolen cars often end up there before being shipped overseas.
Earlier this month, the federal government announced $28 million to fight the export of stolen vehicles by giving the Canada Border Services Agency more resources to detect and search containers.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Poilievre unrepentant over calling Trudeau 'wacko' as his MPs say Speaker should resign
Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre says he does not regret calling Prime Minister Justin Trudeau 'wacko,' and now his MPs are renewing calls for the House of Commons Speaker to resign, this time over ordering the Official Opposition leader to leave the chamber.
How can I tell if I have norovirus? Expert explains symptoms
The highly contagious norovirus is spreading across Canada, with some symptoms overlapping with other viruses. CTVNews.ca spoke with a health expert to find out how you can tell you have norovirus, the most common form of stomach flu, and what to do if you have it.
Doctors dealing with at least 160 Canadians suffering eye damage possibly linked to looking at the eclipse
Nearly a month after the total solar eclipse, at least 160 cases of eye damage have been reported across the country.
Ontario's police watchdog continues probe of high-speed pursuit involving fatal crash
The investigation continues into a collision that killed two grandparents and their infant grandchild during a high-speed police chase on the wrong way of Highway 401 east of Toronto.
Stranded cruise passengers in Spain race to catch up with their ship
A month after eight Norwegian Cruise Line passengers were stranded in Africa when their ship left without them because they were late getting back, a U.S. couple – ages 84 and 81 – were also left behind by the cruise line in Spain.
Blair says he couldn't sell cabinet on meeting 'magical threshold' of NATO target
Defence Minister Bill Blair says he couldn't convince the Liberal cabinet that Canada's government needed to meet NATO's spending target in its recent defence policy update.
BREAKING London Drugs stores remain closed for 4th straight day after 'cybersecurity incident'
Dozens of London Drugs stores in Western Canada remained closed for the fourth straight day following a "cybersecurity incident."
No criminal charges after 4 newborn bodies found in Boston freezer
A prosecutor in Massachusetts won't seek criminal charges against anyone, two years after four newborns were found in a freezer in a South Boston apartment.
Anger can harm your blood vessel function, study shows
Stress and anger can have a negative impact on cardiovascular health, studies have shown. New research points to just how the mechanism may work.