Trans-rights advocates raise alarm over Quebec birth certificate proposal, calling it 'huge regression'
The Quebec government quietly proposed a legal change on Thursday that trans-rights advocates are raising an alarm over, saying it's regressive.
Under a new bill, Quebecers would only be allowed to request a change of sex on their birth certificate after first undergoing surgery on their sexual organs, according to the bill's terminology.
The change was drafted as a response to a court judgment earlier this year forcing Quebec to be more accommodating to transgender people, but it doesn't accomplish that, advocates said.
Instead, they said, it's a step backwards. Right now, Quebecers can change the sex designation on their birth certificates if it doesn't correspond with their gender identity, without having to undergo any sort of medical treatment.
The proposed changes, tabled as part of Bill 2 on family law, would give transgender people two new options instead of the one they have now -- but neither is better than the current system, advocates say.
People who have not had surgery would have the option of requesting the "sex" category on their birth certificate be renamed as "gender," and then to put down the gender that matches their identity.
But birth certificates would only look this way for people who have requested such a change, automatically "outing" anyone who goes that route, trans-rights advocates told CTV.
The only way to change the "sex" catagory would be undergoing surgery -- something many choose not to do, and in some cases can sterilize the recipient, advocates said.
“It's really disheartening," said Florence Ashley, a Montreal trans-rights activist and doctorate in law student at the University of Toronto.
Right now, Quebec has "one of the most progressive laws in Canada in that regard, and now we're going backwards," Ashley said.
“It’s really a massive surprise, and really adds a climate of fear."
The fear is partly over what government could do next, if it has taken this step, Ashley said.
“If we can have this law, what's going to happen in the future?" they said. "What's going to happen to trans communities? Does the government even care at all?”
RESPONSE TO A COURT RULING
The bill, tabled at the National Assembly on Thursday, would change the first and second paragraphs of the Section 71 of Quebec's Civil Code, which lays out the rules for changing the sex on a Quebecer’s birth certificate.
In a statement, Quebec's Justice Department said that the proposal was meant to fulfill the requirements of a court judgment.
There was a ruling in this area from the Quebec Superior Court last January. It touched a few matters around transgender people and birth certificates, though none that appear to match up directly with what the province proposed this week.
Among other changes, the ruling dropped the age limit for changing birth certificate sex designations, saying Quebecers age 14 and up should able to apply to make the change on their own and without a medical note.
It also allowed non-binary people -- those who don't identify as male or female -- the right to alter their birth certificates to enter a third gender option other than M or F.
The judge in question gave the Quebec government until Dec. 31 to make the changes.
On Friday, Quebec's Justice Department told CTV News that the bill was meant to satisfy that ruling, though it didn't explain exactly how.
"It should be noted that the provisions provided for in Bill 2 will make it possible to respond to the judgment of the Court in the case involving, in particular, the Centre for Gender Advocacy," a department spokesperson wrote.
The Centre for Gender Advocacy is the Montreal organization that was the plaintiff in the January case.
OUTING ONESELF CAN BE 'LIFE OR DEATH'
A representative from the organization said that while they were aware a family law bill was coming, the content of the bill was a "huge shock," and a "huge regression," that would put people in danger.
“This basically means outing yourself, which … can oftentimes be life or death for trans person,” said Celeste Trianon, a trans-rights advocate from the Centre for Gender Advocacy.
Trianon called the bill an example of "systemic transphobia" and said that they didn't see it as "a logical response at all" to the court ruling's requirements.
"The logical response would have been to take the lead and further advance trans rights, or just insert all of the victories obtained in [the January ruling] without doing much more."
Transgender Canadians are at a "much higher" risk of being the victims of violence since the age of 15, according to government data.
They are also more likely to experience “inappropriate behaviors” in public, online, and at work than cisgender people (people who identify with their birth-assigned sex).
The rest of the bill dealt with other matters of family law, including laying out newly proposed regulations for surrogate pregnancies.
A RETURN TO OLD WAYS
Surgery has not been a requirement to change a person’s sex designation on their birth certificate since 2015.
Under that version of the code, an operation was the only way to change the sex of the applicant, who also had to be a Canadian citizen living in Quebec for at least a year.
On Oct. 10 of that year, the rules were made closer to what they are today, specifically that a Quebecer who wanted to change their sex would not need to undergo “any medical treatment or surgical operation whatsoever.”
“This is a regressive change that puts all trans people who have not had genital surgery at risk,” said Jennifer Maccarone, Liberal MNA for Westmount and the party’s spokesperson for the LGBTQ2 community.
In a Saturday morning statement, the party cautioned Bill 2 could push people to get surgery who otherwise wouldn’t want or need it.
It will, Maccarone said, “force unwilling people to have it.”
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Parliamentary report on Emergencies Act decision is 18 months past due — and counting
The erstwhile group of senators and MPs studying the federal government's invocation of the Emergencies Act over the "Freedom Convoy" was supposed to present its findings in December. December of 2022, that is.
Grandparents killed in wrong-way crash on Hwy. 401 identified
A 60-year-old man and a 55-year-old woman killed in a wrong-way crash on Highway 401 earlier this week have been identified by the Consulate General of India in Toronto.
The kids from 'Mrs. Doubtfire are all SUPER grown up now, and we're not OK
The adorable trio of child actors from the 1993 classic comedy 'Mrs. Doubtfire,' which starred the late and great Robin Williams, are all grown up and looking back on their seminal time together.
Quebec man who threatened Trudeau, Legault online sentenced to 20 months in jail
A Quebec man who pleaded guilty to threatening Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and Premier François Legault has been sentenced to 20 months in jail.
Drone footage shows Ukrainian village battered to ruins as residents flee Russian advance
The Ukrainian village of Ocheretyne has been battered by fighting, drone footage obtained by The Associated Press shows. The village has been a target for Russian forces in the Donetsk region of eastern Ukraine.
Bystander livestreams during Charlotte standoff show an ever-growing appetite for social media video
Saing Chhoeun was locked out of his Charlotte, N.C., home on Monday as law enforcement with high-powered rifles descended into his yard and garage, using a car as a shield as they were met with a shower of gunfire from the direction of his neighbor's house.
Britney Spears 'home and safe' after paramedics responded to an incident at the Chateau Marmont, source tells CNN
A source close to singer Britney Spears tells CNN that the pop star is 'home and safe' after she had a 'major fight' with her boyfriend on Wednesday night at the Chateau Marmont in West Hollywood.
Israel has briefed U.S. on plan to evacuate Palestinian civilians ahead of potential Rafah operation
Israel this week briefed Biden administration officials on a plan to evacuate Palestinian civilians ahead of a potential operation in the southern Gaza city of Rafah aimed at rooting out Hamas militants, according to U.S. officials familiar with the talks.
TD worst-case scenario more likely after drug money laundering allegations: analyst
TD Bank Group could be hit with more severe penalties than previously expected, says a banking analyst after a report that the investigation it faces in the U.S. is tied to laundering illicit fentanyl profits.