Quebec Court of Appeal rejects challenge to allocation of family physicians
The Quebec Court of Appeal ruled that the allocation plan for family physicians and the method used by the Minister of Health were valid.
The ruling means Dr. Mark Roper and his lawyer, Julius Grey, did not convince the judges that there was a real injustice to the population of Montreal.
In an e-mail to The Canadian Press, Grey expressed his disappointment and said he was considering taking his case to the Supreme Court.
In the decision signed by Justices Stephen W. Hamilton, Martin Vauclair and Frédéric Bachand, the court upheld the trial decision handed down by Judge Dominique Poulin. The "meticulous" nature of the Superior Court's judgment was also emphasized.
The argument put forward by Grey and Dr. Roper is that Montreal is at a disadvantage compared to the majority of Quebec regions. According to Dr. Roper's figures, the city has the worst registration rate with a family doctor and, from one year to the next, the minister uses his discretionary power to deprive the metropolis of new doctors in favour of other regions.
The petitioners argued that the system was "unreasonable" and even violated the Canadian Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms.
However, the judges of the Court of Appeal came to the same conclusion as Justice Poulin, namely that the insufficient number of primary care family physicians "does not result from the minister's allocation of resources, but rather from the insufficient number of physicians to meet the needs at the provincial level."
In his petition, Dr. Roper also denounced the fact that the calculation used to allocate the workforce did not take into account the rate of registration with a family doctor. He also criticized the Ministry of Health for not considering the actual pool of patients served by Montreal and for relying solely on the number of inhabitants.
The judges reiterated, however, that it was not the role of the courts to substitute for legislative, executive or administrative powers in this situation.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published in French on Oct. 27, 2023.
The Canadian Press health content receives funding through a partnership with the Canadian Medical Association. The Canadian Press is solely responsible for editorial choices.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Polls close for closely watched byelections in Montreal and Winnipeg
The NDP has a slight early lead in Winnipeg while remaining in a three-way race with the Liberals and the Bloc Québécois in Montreal as ballots continue to be counted in two crucial federal byelections.
GoFundMe cancels fundraiser for Ontario woman charged with spraying neighbour with a water gun
A Simcoe, Ont., woman charged with assault with a weapon after accidentally spraying her neighbour with a water gun says GoFundMe has now pulled the plug on her online fundraiser.
Freeland says she is 'not going anywhere' after Conservatives call her 'phantom finance minister'
Deputy Prime Minister Chrystia Freeland declared she is 'not going anywhere' when pushed by the Conservatives on Monday about her future as finance minister.
Suspect in apparent assassination attempt on Trump was near golf course for 12 hours
The man suspected in an apparent assassination attempt targeting Donald Trump camped outside a golf course with food and a rifle for nearly 12 hours.
Body recovered from B.C. lake after unclothed man leads investigators to crash site
Mounties are investigating a fatal crash north of Whistler, B.C., after an unclothed man who was found along the side of the road led police to a pickup truck submerged in a lake with one occupant still inside.
'Never seen anything like this': Humpback whale catches unsuspecting seal off Vancouver Island
A Vancouver Island nature photographer says he has never seen anything like what his camera captured on a recent whale-watching excursion off Victoria.
'Not that simple': Trump drags Canadian river into California's water problems
Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump promised "more water than you ever saw" to Californians, partly by tapping resources from a Canadian river.
Mortgage loan rules are changing in Canada
Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland has announced changes to mortgage rules she says are aimed at helping more Canadians to purchase their first home.
First teen sentenced in Kenneth Lee case gets 15 months probation
The first teenager to be sentenced in the death of a Toronto homeless man will not face further time in custody, and instead participate in a community-based program.