Montreal comic book artists claim Marvel abusing legal system in copyright battle
Montreal comic-book artist Ray Lai said that no matter the time, effort or legal expense, he and his brother Ben will defend their work, even if it's against a force as powerful as the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU).
"If you come up with an original idea, it's your job to protect it, and if you don't do it, you might as well not do it anymore," the artist told CTV News.
The Lai brothers are embroiled in a legal fight against Marvel and Disney, who they say stole design elements in the film versions featuring the characters Iron Man, Ant-Man and the Wasp.
A recently filed abuse of process motion argues that the industry juggernauts have tried to delay or dismiss their copyright infringement case using deceitful tactics.
"The defendants appear to be acting with the intention of drowning the plaintiff procedures and documentation and thus exhaust them financially," the motion reads. "In addition to the unnecessary steps that the plaintiffs [Lai brothers] have had to take... the claimant has had to deal with a number of unnecessary objections and unreasonable positions of the defendants."
Since the proceedings began in 2021, the Lai brothers' lawyer, Julie Desrosiers, said Marvel has attempted to dismiss the case, objected to key witnesses being deposed, and tried to bury the lawyers in documents without title, all while increasing fees for her clients and delaying the case unnecessarily.
"We realized that they did some things that misled the court and misled us with respect to revenues and profits deriving from these films in Canada," said Desrosiers. "We decided to file a motion for abuse of process so that the Lai brothers can recuperate some of the fees that they spent in fighting against these proceedings."
The motion seeks almost $180,000 to recoup legal fees that have mounted for the Lai brothers.
Montreal-based comic book artist Ben and Ray Lai, claim elements from their Radix comic designs (left) were used in Marvel's Iron Man 3 suit and subsequent images. The brothers are suing Marvel and Disney. (Court document)
"I don't want to sound cliche and say it's our baby, but when you start doing something, you have to if you really believe in it, you have to go all the way," said Ray Lai. "You can't just say, 'well, you know, somebody takes it, I'm just going to start over,' then everybody's gonna just keep [taking it]."
The brothers allege in their original suit that Marvel used designs from the Lai brothers' Radix series in its Iron Man and Ant-Man costumes for Marvel's blockbuster films.
The brothers are seeking compensatory damages and or "profits that marvel obtained as a result of the infringement, in an amount to be determined after full inquiry." They also asked for the court to issue Marvel and Disney a " permanent injunction to put an end to this deliberate and persistent infringement."
Desrosiers said experts have estimated a potential settlement to be over $5 million.
Copying work from the beginning
The Lai brothers started creating comics in 1995 and quickly made a name for themselves in the industry, getting hired by CrossGen Comics before returning to Montreal to develop the Radix series, published by Image Comics from 2001 to 2002.
The joy of seeing their work in print was coupled with the frustration of finding out a harsh reality in the industry.
"Right off the first issue, we had MIT (Massachusetts Institue of Technology) copying our work," said Ray Lai.
Professor Edwin L. Thomas said he unknowingly used an image from the brothers in a research proposal about the soldier of the future in 2002.
He published an apology on MIT's site after speaking to the brothers.
"If I had known it was your work, I would not have used it," he wrote. "MIT strongly supports the rights of creators and greatly regrets using the image without permission or credit. I am very sorry that this occurred; it won't happen again."
Thomas explained in his apology that his team decided to include a drawing of what a soldier of the future might look like and included one of the Lai brothers' characters.
"I didn't know until after your attorney contacted MIT at the end of April that the image apparently was based on your character," Thomas said.. As soon as we heard about that, I had it removed from the Institute for Soldier Nanotechnology web pages, notified all of those involved not to use the image for any purpose, and MIT also ordered the image removed from all MIT web sites."
Shortly after the MIT scandal, the brothers were fired by Marvel, where they worked for around a year before returning to Montreal to work on their own comics.
When the brothers saw the poster for Ironman 3, Ray said they immediately recognized their work.
"Right off the bat, I said, Well, that's, that's a copy," said Ray. "And, the interesting thing is, we do know a lot of the people that were at Marvel."
Ray and Ben had worked with many of the designers who worked on the films, and also that Marvel knew about the MIT case, further fueling their desire to ensure their work was defended.
"When they hired us, they knew MIT copied us," said Lai. "So now they're copying us again."
Further films featuring Ant-Man and The Wasp are also part of the brothers' case.
Original images from the Ant-Man comic series (left) then one from the Lai brothers' Radix series (middle) and images from Marvel's Endgame and Ant-Man and the Wasp (right) are the source of a copyright infringement case before the courts. (Court document)
After cases were dismissed in the U.S., the Lai brothers filed suit in Quebec Superior Court.
All claims have yet to be proven in court.
The Quebec law firm representing Disney/Marvel, Robic, did not respond to multiple CTV News requests for comment. Marvel is defending the lawsuit in court.
'No point in creating if you cannot protect'
For the Lai brothers, the exhausting legal proceedings, though frustrating, are worth going through.
"I think, even back in the day when MIT copied us, the important thing that I thought is there was no point in creating if you cannot protect your intellectual property because that is the most important thing," said Ray. "It's great to be an artist, it's great to put stuff out there and people can appreciate it, but if you cannot protect your work."
The original comic book version of The Wasp (left), Horizon's Radix comic design (centre), and Marvel's design for the 'Ant-Man and the Wasp' film. (Court document)
The same is true for the company the Lai brothers are suing.
Marvel filed suit against four artists for copyright interests in Iron Man, Ant-Man and Captain Marvel, and resolved the suit in 2023.
"They own their intellectual property, and they'll do everything in their power to protect it," said Ray Lai. "And if we cannot protect it, then there's no point in just doing work so that other people can take advantage of it... I think that's, that's why it's just a big part of being a creator."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Israeli attack on Rafah tent camp kills 45, prompts global outcry
An Israeli airstrike triggered a massive blaze killing 45 people in a tent camp in the Gaza city of Rafah, officials said on Monday, prompting an outcry from global leaders who urged the implementation of a World Court ruling to halt Israel's assault.
A cross-country look at beer and wine in convenience stores
By Labour Day weekend, Ontarians of legal drinking age could snag a six-pack at their local convenience store on the way to the cottage. But what are alcohol sales like across the country? Here's what we know.
Former 'General Hospital' actor Johnny Wactor fatally shot in Los Angeles
Former 'General Hospital' actor Johnny Wactor was fatally shot in downtown Los Angeles while interrupting thieves Saturday, according to his agent and CNN affiliate KABC.
Kingston, Ont. tenants fed up with lack of action from landlord over broken floor tiles
Joel Felder and Misti Pitcher have been living in their apartment in Kingston, Ont. for over two years, but the past 12 months have been miserable.
Are you a loud snorer? You could have sleep apnea
You'll have a lot more energy throughout the day if you get a good night's sleep, but not everyone does due to a medical condition.
North Korea appears to have fired a missile into the sea, Japan and South Korea say
Japan says North Korea has launched a missile into the sea and has alerted residents on Okinawa island to seek shelter.
U of T protesters don't plan to pack up, will hold rally at eviction deadline
Pro-Palestinian protesters who have been camped out at the University of Toronto for weeks say they have no plans to honour the terms of a trespass notice issued by the school and clear the demonstration site by 8 a.m. today.
She developed a passion for genealogy while finding her roots. Now she helps others find their own
Lauren Robilliard always knew she was adopted. As the B.C. native grew older, she developed a passion for genealogy, tracing her roots and paving the way for a career to help others find their own.
The dreams of a 60-year-old beauty contestant come to an abrupt end in Argentina
A 60-year-old woman saw her dreams of becoming the oldest Miss Universe contestant in history melt away in a haze of sequins and selfies Saturday at Argentina’s annual beauty pageant.