Quebec cites 'social peace' to extend notwithstanding clause on secularism law
The Quebec government tabled legislation Thursday to continue shielding the province's secularism law -- known as Bill 21 -- from court challenges over Charter violations.
The application of the Constitution's notwithstanding clause for another five years is needed to maintain "social peace" in the province, Jean-Francois Roberge, the minister responsible for secularism, told reporters.
Bill 21 was passed in June 2019 and prohibits public servants deemed to be in positions of authority -- including teachers, police officers and judges -- from wearing religious symbols such as the hijab, turban or kippah on the job. The law sparked outrage among religious minorities across Canada. A challenge to the legislation is currently before the province's highest court, but because of the notwithstanding clause lawyers have been limited in the arguments they can present.
Roberge called Bill 21 an extremely important achievement. "It currently preserves, I would say, social peace, it promotes coexistence. That's why we absolutely must renew the notwithstanding clause," he said.
The Charter of Rights and Freedoms stipulates that the notwithstanding clause -- which protects legislation from challenges over Charter violations -- can be applied to legislation for five years, after which time a government has to renew it.
According to Roberge, Bill 21 has brought "extremely important clarifications for the government, educational institutions, municipalities, courts, police, on what can and cannot be done, the way to handle requests for reasonable accommodations."
Both the Quebec government and groups opposing Bill 21 are challenging an April 2021 Superior Court decision that largely upheld the controversial legislation but struck down provisions relating to English-language school boards and a ban on face coverings for members of the provincial legislature. Seventeen separate parties are challenging the law. The Quebec Court of Appeal heard arguments for and against the law in November 2022 and hasn't yet released a ruling.
The official Opposition Liberals oppose the extension of the notwithstanding clause, saying there is no justification for suspending fundamental freedoms. "The notwithstanding clause … is so broad that it suspends fundamental rights and freedoms that have no connection to Bill 21," said Liberal interim Leader Marc Tanguay.
But the Coalition Avenir Quebec has a majority government, and the other two opposition parties, the Parti Quebecois and Quebec solidaire, also support the extension of the clause.
PQ member Pascal Berube told reporters Thursday that not only does his party like Bill 21, it thinks it should be expanded to cover daycare workers.
Meanwhile, Quebec solidaire spokesman Gabriel Nadeau-Dubois says that while his party doesn't support Bill 21, it also doesn't think the legislation should be struck down over a possible violation of the Canadian Constitution. The law, he said, should be changed by Quebec's legislature.
"It's a bad law for Quebec, but these are debates that must take place in Quebec, which must be settled by Quebec's institutions and charters," Nadeau-Dubois said.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Feb. 8, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
TD penalties expected to be higher on alleged drug money laundering link: analyst
A banking analyst says TD Bank Group could be hit with more severe penalties than previously expected after a report that the investigation it faces in the U.S. is tied to laundering illicit fentanyl profits.
DEVELOPING Foreign interference inquiry to report today on alleged meddling in federal elections
A federal commission of inquiry into foreign interference is slated to release a report today on alleged meddling in the last two general elections.
Magnitude 4.8 earthquake recorded west of Vancouver Island
A 4.8-magnitude earthquake was reported west of Vancouver Island Thursday evening.
Biscuits with possible plastic pieces, metal found in ground pork: Here are the recalls for this week
Here are the latest recalls Canadians should watch out for, according to Health Canada and the Canadian Food Inspection Agency.
How falling for a stranger she met on a beach led this woman to ditch the U.S. for the French Riviera
Niki Benjamin, from the U.S., had travelled to a paradise island to do some soul searching, and her life ended up going in a very different direction when her dog ran up to a stranger.
Britney Spears 'home and safe' after paramedics responded to an incident at the Chateau Marmont, source tells CNN
A source close to singer Britney Spears tells CNN that the pop star is 'home and safe' after she had a 'major fight' with her boyfriend on Wednesday night at the Chateau Marmont in West Hollywood.
Princess Anne to take part in B.C. ceremony bringing new ship into Pacific fleet
Western Canada's first Arctic and Offshore Patrol Vessel will officially be brought into the Pacific fleet today and Princess Anne, the sister of King Charles, is scheduled to take part in its commissioning ceremony.
BREAKING Winnipeg man accused of killing four women will be tried by jury
A Winnipeg man accused of killing four Indigenous women will have his case heard by a jury.
Wally, the emotional support alligator once denied entry to a baseball game, is missing
Emotional support animal registrations in the United States reached 115,832 last year, by an industry group’s count. But in the eyes of reptile rescuer Joie Henney, there’s only one: 'Wally Gator.'