McGill law professors say school has 'a legal obligation' to enforce mandatory vaccines for on-campus attendance
More than 1,000 people have signed an online petition demanding McGill University make vaccines mandatory for students on-campus, while voices from each side debate whether it would be legal to do so.
Without mandatory vaccines, members of McGill’s own law faculty say the school could be leaving itself open to lawsuits from the university community.
Earlier in August, McGill student Phaedra de Saint-Rome launched the petition after the University of Ottawa decided to make vaccines mandatory for all students returning to campus in-person.
She says McGill should do everything in its power to keep students from contracting COVID-19, and that a vaccine requirement is an important step in doing so.
“The science says that the best course of action, and the best way to stay safe, is to be vaccinated and to continue wearing a mask, particularly in close spaces,” she said.
“So, I'm hoping that [McGill] will follow that science.”
The university says it is not legally allowed to make vaccines mandatory for students without an explicit government directive.
This week, the Legault government announced vaccinations are mandatory for health-care workers and students in health-care programs.
For now, educators and students in other departments are not being forced to get the shot.
“Our view is that unless the government mandates vaccination, in the Quebec context we cannot legally require it,” wrote McGill spokesperson Katherine Gombay in a statement to CTV News.
“McGill will continue to take a prudent planning approach that allows us to adapt as the health and well-being of our community remains a top priority.”
But that claim was refuted by members of the university’s law faculty, who wrote an open letter to McGill claiming there is no legal reason the school can’t impose its own vaccine requirement (letter attached below this article).
“We have concluded that the university not only has the legal authority to institute such a policy but has a legal obligation to do so,” read the letter.
“Usually, when you ask someone, what's your (legal) reasoning, they give you one, but they give everyone the exact same sentence you got,” Richard Gold, a McGill law professor, told CTV News.
“So, we looked far and wide,” he said, adding he and others combed privacy, employment, and human rights laws, as well as the Canadian and Quebec charters.
“We could find nothing that prevented McGill or sister universities from instituting such a program,” he said.
“None of us have any clue why McGill is taking this position.”
A LEGAL LIABILITY?
Gold says that without a mandatory vaccine policy, the school may be leaving itself open to legal action from students and staff.
A lawsuit, according to Gold, could come from one of two groups of people.
The first group, he says, includes students, faculty, and staff who have health conditions that put them at a greater risk of COVID-19 complications.
Or, he says, those who have children under 12, or are taking care of someone with a health condition.
“They will sue under discrimination,” he said, “and we have quite robust anti-discrimination laws based on disability.”
The second group, says Gold, includes those who get sick because a classmate is unvaccinated.
“Either they then themselves get seriously ill, or they pass it on to someone else,” said Gold.
“Then, McGill could be sued for civil liability for having failed to meet the standard that has emerged in the world” in universities elsewhere, he said.
“In the end, it will depend on a court of law,” he added. “All we're saying is there is a legal risk here.”
Read the open letter here:
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
'Immoral depravity': Two men convicted in case of frozen migrant family in Manitoba
A jury has found two men guilty on human smuggling charges in a case where a family from India froze to death in Manitoba while trying to walk across the Canada-U.S. border.
Canada's tax relief plan: Who gets a cheque?
The Canadian government has unveiled its plans for a sweeping GST/HST pause on select items during the holiday period. The day after the announcement, questions remain on how the whole thing will work.
Quebec man, 81, gets prison sentence after admitting to killing wife with Alzheimer's disease
An 81-year-old Quebec man has been sentenced to prison after admitting to killing his wife with Alzheimer's disease.
Canada Post losses top $300M as strike enters second week -- and rivals step in
Canada Post saw hundreds of millions of dollars drain out of its coffers last quarter, due largely to its dwindling share of the parcels market, while an ongoing strike continues to batter its bottom line.
Nearly 46,000 electric vehicles recalled in Canada over potential power loss
Nearly 46,000 electric vehicles from Kia, Hyundai and Genesis are being recalled in Canada over a potential power loss issue that can increase the risk of a crash.
Pat King found guilty of mischief for role in 'Freedom Convoy'
Pat King, one of the most prominent figures of the 2022 'Freedom Convoy' in Ottawa, has been found guilty on five counts including mischief and disobeying a court order.
Canada issues travel warning after 6 people die from tainted alcohol in Laos
The Canadian government is warning travellers following the deaths of at least six people in the mass poisoning of foreign tourists in Laos after drinking tainted alcohol.
Ground beef tied to U.S. E. coli recall, illnesses wasn't sold in Canada: distributor
At least 15 people have been sickened by E. coli poisoning tied to a recall of potentially tainted ground beef, U.S. federal health officials said. The company tells CTVNews.ca it was not sold in Canada.
Canada's new income tax brackets in 2025: What you need to know
The Canada Revenue Agency has released updated federal income tax brackets for 2025, reflecting adjustments for inflation. Here’s the breakdown.