A 'deplorable' decision: Quebec prosecutors told to prioritize more serious crimes due to court delays
Legal groups in Quebec are condemning a new directive that forces prosecutors to prioritize the completion of more serious criminal offences than others in order to clear backlogs in the justice system.
Citing the need to address court delays, the head of the Directeur des poursuites criminelles et pénales (DPCP), Patrick Michael, issued a directive on Thursday ordering prosecutors to prioritize cases involving death or serious injury, sexual or domestic violence, as well as elder and child abuse, in order to move them forward in a quicker fashion.
The new decision from Quebec's Crown prosecution office means cases like theft, criminal harassment, mischief and other offences not listed in the new instructions could be prosecuted at a slower pace in Quebec courts.
The union representing prosecutors in Quebec called it a "deplorable" decision that puts them in precarious situations.
"Under the circumstances, it is not a big surprise, but it is extremely concerning. The real consequence is that people can now get away with criminal acts. This sends a wrong message to victims and to the public. Prosecutors are now faced with agonizing choices. It is like asking a doctor to choose which patient to operate on," said Guillaume Michaud, president of Association des procureurs aux poursuites criminelles et pénales, in a statement to CTV News.
"When we as a society are confronted with a justice system that has to prioritize certain crimes, for us, as prosecutors, it makes no sense."
The more serious crimes should go to the front of the line in order to ensure they are "within the Jordan timelines," the directive said, in reference to the Supreme Court's Jordan decision in 2016.
That landmark ruling set new limits on how long an accused person can wait for a trial to be completed. In provincial courts, the time limit is 18 months from the time a person is charged. In higher courts, it's 30 months.
Cases that go beyond the timelines set by Canada's highest court would be considered an unresaonble delay and a violation of a person's right to a speedy trial under section 11 of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
The DPCP's new prioritization strategy asks prosecutors to consult with the deputy or chief prosecutor when there is a concern that an "objectively or subjectively more serious offence" is at risk of being delayed.
It also requires them to consider the public interest implications of giving priority to certain cases, such as: the damage or loss caused by the offence; the prevalence of the offence in the community; the amount of resources devoted to the police investigation; and the "effect that a stay of proceedings for unreasonable delay would have on public order or public confidence in the administration of justice."
It's not just prosecutors who are unhappy with the decision. The Barreau du Québec, the professional order that oversees more than 29,000 lawyers in the province, also "deplores" the new directive.
"The Bar believes that this is unfortunately one of the consequences of the underfunding of [the] justice [system]," said Quebec Bar president Catherine Claveau in a statement to CTV News.
"The Barreau du Québec maintains that it is essential to prioritize justice and ensure adequate funding to avoid the delays and service disruptions that we are currently observing."
On Friday, André Morin, the Quebec Liberal Party's justice critic, said on Twitter that the prioritization of court cases is a sign of the "failure" of the Quebec government and called on the justice minister to "act now."
La Presse reported Friday that Justice Minister Simon Jolin-Barrette said the new instructions for judges are a direct consequence of the Court of Quebec's decision to require judges to sit every other day rather than every third day. The new ratios put more than 50,000 cases at risk of exceeding the Jordan limits, Jolin-Barrette calculated.
Still at a crossroads, the justice minister and Lucie Rondeau, the chief justice of the Court of Quebec, agreed to name retired Quebec Court of Appeal Judge Jacques Chamberland to act as a mediator to settle the disagreement.
The process started last month and is confidential.
Last summer, lawyers sounded the alarm over court delays at the Montreal courthouse, which struggled with a shortage of judges, special constables and clerks.
Criminal lawyer Alexandre Goyette said in an interview last June that bail hearings — proceedings in which the court must decide whether a person charged with an offence can be conditionally released while awaiting trial — are normally held within three days, but were actually taking as long as 30 days to be completed.
With files from The Canadian Press
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
DEVELOPING Trump open to using 'economic force' to acquire Canada as a state
"Canada and the United States, that would really be something," said U.S. president-elect Donald Trump during a Mar-a-Lago press conference on Tuesday. 'You get rid of that artificially drawn line, and you take a look at what that looks like.'
Trump refuses to rule out use of military force to take control of Greenland and the Panama Canal
U.S. president-elect Donald Trump on Tuesday said he would not rule out the use of military force to seize control of the Panama Canal and Greenland, as he declared U.S. control of both to be vital to American national security.
As walking pneumonia rates drop among Canadian children, flu and RSV are back
Following a sharp rise, cases of walking pneumonia across Canada, particularly among children, seem to be dropping.
2 sons of Mexican cartel leader 'El Chapo' are in plea negotiations with U.S., attorneys say
Two sons of notorious Mexican drug kingpin 'El Chapo' facing sweeping drug-trafficking charges in the U.S. are in plea negotiations with the federal government, attorneys acknowledged Tuesday in a Chicago courtroom.
Ontario launches border-strengthening operation as Trump tariff threat looms
The Ontario government says it has launched an operation intended to beef up security along the border with the United States.
CRA to continue with capital tax changes despite prorogation: finance department
The federal government says the Canada Revenue Agency will continue to administer the capital gains tax, even though it hasn't passed in Parliament, which is prorogued until March 24.
Aubrey Plaza addresses 'unimaginable tragedy' of losing her husband
Aubrey Plaza has shared her first statement since the death of her husband, writer and director Jeff Baena.
Justin Trudeau's set to go after the Liberals pick his replacement, what now?
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau, announcing Monday that he intends to resign as Liberal leader and prime minister as soon as his party names his replacement, has set a series of political machinations in motion.
Bank CEO worries shift to political uncertainty as mortgage risks ease
The heads of Canada's biggest banks are finally seeing risks around mortgage renewals easing, only for worries about tariffs and political uncertainty to take their place.