Two young ER doctors quit Montreal jobs, blaming Quebec's broken health-care system and Bill 96
Two young emergency room doctors, raised and trained in Montreal, are leaving their jobs after only two years to move back to Toronto – and they say the Quebec health-care model and Bill 96 are to blame.
The doctors, who work at the Jewish General Hospital, are headed back to Ontario, a move they've made before – but this time, they say they don't expect to return home anytime soon.
The married couple says they can't see a way forward in Quebec for themselves and their two boys, aged three and one.
So two different Toronto emergency rooms are preparing for their arrival, with jobs waiting for them.
"It was a really tough decision," said Dr. Daria Denissova, 34. Her husband, Dr. Philip Stasiak, 37, said they made it "with a heavy heart."
"I love Montreal. It's the city I grew up in, and to leave it again for the second time, it's disappointing," Stasiak said.
They are leaving at a time when the Quebec health-care system has been heavily criticized for being fragile.
Montreal alone is short 18,399 health-care workers, according to the government's July 4 health-care system dashboard.
But after all their agonizing, it became clear to the doctors that compared to the hospital system they remember in Toronto, Montreal's working conditions, which they consider to be tough and inflexible, are incompatible with raising a healthy family. They say those conditions are a natural consequence of government rules limiting hiring.
And if they still had doubts about the move, Quebec's new language law, commonly known as Bill 96, sealed the deal for them.
The doctors have no trouble communicating with patients in French or English. They're trilingual: Denissova also speaks Russian, Stasiak speaks Polish.
But they're somewhat concerned that the law aimed at protecting the French language could affect patient care and make an already fraught workplace all the more burdensome.
"It's very fuzzy. What are going to be the true implications of this? Is it political posturing? How are the laws going to be applied?" Stasiak said. "No one really knows."
He expects at the English-designated hospital he works at, he'd be able to continue to use his better judgment, but the unknowns still rankle.
Will it be felt in "my interactions with patients, is it my interactions with my colleagues, when I speak to a consultant or a nurse or someone else from an allied health profession? What about my charting?" he said.
"We're perfectly bilingual, but the thing is, there are so many acronyms in medicine... and to describe that to someone else who needs to have that information transmitted… wouldn't it be better to continue it that way?" Stasiak said.
"I don't like it, as a principle, that you should dictate as to who I should speak to in English or in French," Denissova said, when what matters most is communicating effectively with patients.
"It's infuriating that this is even a conversation to have," she added. "Are people going to have to show their eligibility certificates when you go to the hospital for care?"
They aren't alone in their concerns. Other medical groups, namely Quebec's College of Physicians, have been sounding the alarm about Bill 96 for months.
In an email to CTV News on Monday, Quebec's College of Physicians reiterated that the organization "will remain vigilant" regarding Bill 96 as "the reform could have an impact on the doctor-patient relationship."
"I just didn't want to live in a place where I didn't feel, anymore, was representing my views and values," said Denissova.
THREE PRIORITIES: FAMILY, FRENCH FLUENCY AND FREEDOM OF CHOICE
The much larger issue looming over the young parents, however, is how Bill 96 might limit their children's academic choices when they get to CEGEP age, and after they'd attended French elementary and high schools, as their parents did when they were kids.
"We would want them to have the freedom to choose between, 'You know what? I want to go to an English CEGEP or a French CEGEP,' which is the choice that we had made," said Stasiak.
But they fear changes in the language law might make that impossible.
Bill 96 caps enrolment levels at English-language CEGEPs, and it's expected to make the colleges more and more difficult for francophone and allophone students to get into as their growth will be halted at 2019 levels.
Given the restrictions, the pair wants to ensure their children don't spend all their younger years studying in French in a province that might, later on, slam the door on their future success.
"They're freezing English CEGEP enrolment, and they're prioritizing students coming from English schools – and this is now," said Denissova. "What is it going to be in 10 to 15 years?"
The only possible solution would be to send the boys to private English schools in Montreal that offer a grade 12 option, so they could bypass CEGEP altogether and graduate with an Ontario Secondary School diploma.
But then, their French fluency could take a hit, the pair noted. They say they're in a catch-22 unless they leave Quebec.
"I think the biggest irony is that now we're going to be going back to Toronto, we're going to be sending them to a private French school," Denissova said.
"We want them to be perfectly fluent in French... but not at the expense of their future freedom and future choices and career opportunities," she said.
EMERGENCY ROOM COLLEAGUES ARE 'UNDERSTANDING'
The couple says it's hard to believe they've come full circle and are leaving home again.
They left for Ontario the first time because they could not get permits to practice in Montreal after they completed their residencies at McGill University teaching hospitals.
The government determines how many doctors a region or hospital can hire, using a permit distribution system known as PREMs/PEMs (Plan régional d'effectifs médicaux) – and there weren't any available to them.
So for five years, they worked in emergency rooms in Toronto.
"Then, once we had our first child, we decided, you know, it would be really nice to go back. I miss the French. I miss Montreal as a city. We're going to be closer to our parents," Stasiak said.
Those Montreal elements were great for them: the grandparents, the house, the neighbourhood. After about a year, however, reality set in, they said.
"It hit me that, oh my goodness, this is such a rougher work environment and also there was Bill 96 that was all over the news, so all of these things started dawning on me," Denissova said.
She wondered if they could sustain the workload -- many shifts, and shifts 30 to 50 per cent longer than in Toronto, she calculated -- and remain healthy over the next 20-plus years if they continued on the same course.
The environment, they said, has nothing to do with the way their particular hospital is managed, something Denissova observed when she picked up a few ER shifts at a different Montreal hospital to help her understand the issues she was up against.
Both young doctors believe the "onerous" workload has much to do with the province's permit system.
"Because of the PREM system, the work conditions are a lot more difficult. The work is a lot less flexible in terms of hours, in terms of shifts," Denissova said.
When it comes to that assessment, she has an ally in a veteran Montreal GP who has just taken the health ministry to court over the PREM system and the way it's being used to distribute – or not distribute – family doctors in Montreal.
"It doesn't make any sense that we have restrictions on recruitment," Dr. Mark Roper said, "when we have such a lack of personnel, a lack of emergency doctors. That doesn't make sense, right?"
He believes having more family doctors in Montreal would relieve pressure on swamped emergency rooms because the family doctors would see more patients in their offices and do ER rotations.
"We would for sure welcome and benefit from more physicians," Denissova said. She added that she's discouraged to see that doctors decades her senior are still over-working just as much as she and her husband are.
Nor does she envision they will ever have a flexible work schedule that would allow them to provide better care for their children and get them to and from daycare and school – unless various aspects of the system change dramatically.
"This is true," said Roper. "The PREM system and the PEM system, which is more the manpower controls for hospitals, force the heads of departments only to use full-time doctors, and the part-timers have a very difficult time."
They're so short-staffed, said Denissova, that it would put too much pressure on the rest of the team if she were permitted to scale back her hours for a few years – something she will now be able to do in Toronto.
"Pretty much as soon as I spoke to the department in Toronto where I worked before, they said 'Yeah, of course, we'll take you happily, however many shifts you want to work.'"
The hospital told her that "'if you want to work less hard for a few years of your life because you have younger kids, we can accommodate whatever you want,' she said. "So the contrast was striking."
Telling colleagues in the Jewish General ER about their decision was "tough," said Stasiak.
"These are people that we trained with, that we know, that are our friends -- I feel like we're in a way even maybe letting them down a bit, and they're also disappointed," he said.
"But everyone is very understanding. They get it because they see the conditions," he said.
"We need to do what's best for us, for our family," even if that means leaving others behind.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
'The Satanic Verses' author Salman Rushdie was taken off a ventilator and able to talk Saturday, a day after he was stabbed as he prepared to give a lecture in upstate New York.
Police arrested three Arizona parents, shocking two of them with stun guns, as they tried to force their way into a school that police locked down Friday after an armed man was seen trying to get on campus, authorities said.
Kristen Hayes lives close to the hospital in Yarmouth, N.S., but she says that twice in the past month, her son, who has a rare form of epilepsy, has been taken by ambulance to the emergency room there, only to be left waiting.
The Canada Border Services Agency is temporarily allowing fully vaccinated travellers a one-time exemption to not be penalized if they were unaware of the health documents required through ArriveCAN.
Average rent in Canada for all properties rose more than 10 per cent year-over-year in July, according to a recent nationwide analysis of listings on Rentals.ca.
The Los Angeles Police Department has ended its investigation into Anne Heche's car accident, when the actor crashed into a Los Angeles home on Aug. 5.
Volunteers armed with smartphones are using a 3D-modelling app to preserve Ukraine's cultural heritage one snap at a time.
More Canadians are ending their lives with a medically-assisted death, says the third federal annual report on medical assistance in dying (MAID). Data shows that 10,064 people died in 2021 with medical aid, an increase of 32 per cent over 2020.
The FBI recovered documents that were labelled 'top secret' from former U.S. President Donald Trump's Mar-a-Lago estate in Florida, according to court papers released Friday after a federal judge unsealed the warrant that authorized the unprecedented search this week.
About 14 per cent of Ontario hospitals reporting less than a week supply of epidural catheters: Ontario Health
Approximately 14 per cent of hospitals in Ontario are reporting they have less than a week’s worth of epidural catheters in stock, according to an Ontario Health memo sent to hospital chief executive officers on Friday.
A man who allegedly stabbed a woman and held a child inside a Scarborough home was fatally shot by Toronto police officers following an interaction on Saturday afternoon.
A shooting at a plaza parking lot in Vaughan has left one man dead, York Regional Police say.
At this time, the Monkeypox vaccine is not widely available to the public.
Officials in central Newfoundland are asking people to stop using forest roads to check on their cabins even though the threat of wildfires has eased for local communities and a state of emergency has been lifted.
CTV News London has learned that London native and NHL superstar Nazem Kadri will bring the Stanley Cup to London later this month.
Police have arrested a suspect in connection with a shooting in Hanover earlier this week.
'It’s going to look like New York City': Apple TV series to film in downtown London, Ont. this month
One block of Richmond Street is about to transform into New York City. CTV News London has learned the Apple TV series “Improbable Valentine” — based off the book "The Changeling" — will be filming in downtown London later this month.
One person is dead following an ATV collision Saturday afternoon.
A 34-year-old man has been arrested and charged following a homicide in Sudbury on Thursday.
One woman is dead in what police will only call a suspicious death in the city.
Friday night's thunderstorm had Calgarians in every corner of the city watching the skies, but it was too close for comfort for one family in Wildwood.
Sean Whyte's 25-yard field goal with two seconds left in the fourth quarter capped a B.C. Lions' comeback in a 41-40 win over the host Calgary Stampeders on Saturday.
Alberta Premier Jason Kenney condemned a controversial prize-winning essay that's been criticized for being sexist and racist during his provincewide radio call-in program, but also appeared to downplay the controversy it generated.
Those driving through a neighbourhood in Kitchener may want to double check the speed limit.
A total of 67 cattle have been killed after a fire tore through a barn early Saturday morning.
Waterloo Region's public school board has confirmed that "certain student information was accessed" during a cyber incident last month.
Beaches at Richmond's Garry Point Park are closed after the Canadian Coast Guard investigated and try to clean up a recent diesel spill.
A B.C. lawyer has been sentenced to 22 months in jail after pleading guilty to forging documents that he submitted to Canada's Immigration and Refugee Board over a period of nearly 10 years
A high-risk sex offender who went missing soon after being released from prison to a halfway house in Vancouver is back in custody, police said Saturday.
A group of volunteers is regularly conducting community patrols in Chinatown to help document vandalism and make the area a safer space for area businesses and residents.
Canada improved it record to three wins and no losses Saturday at the world junior hockey championship in Edmonton after scoring a 5-1 win against Czechia.
A plane bound for Toronto has been forced to divert to Iceland after a Canadian man allegedly became violent and tried to open the aircraft door mid-air.
Windsor is welcoming the best female softball players between the ages of 12 and 18. This weekend, it’s the U13 Championships at Mic Mac Park.
The Saskatchewan Health Authority (SHA) has alerted the public to the elevated risk of acquiring Monkeypox through anonymous sexual contact.
Regina’s city council is set to consider putting $200,000 towards a bid to host the 2024 Brier.
Canadian Blood Services says it is in talks with companies that pay donors for plasma as it faces a decrease in collections.
Commuters face slowdowns on several roads in Ottawa this weekend, as all eastbound and westbound lanes of Hwy. 417 are closed between Metcalfe Street and Carling/Kirkwood Avenues for the replacement of the Booth Street Bridge.
As rents continue to rise for one-and-two bedroom apartments in Ottawa and Gatineau this summer, a new report shows rents are decreasing in the Ottawa neighbourhoods of Nepean and Gloucester.
There was a swift response from the community to help find a missing bicycle cart owned by a popular ice cream shop.
A group of young musicians, creators and performers capped off a week-long camp with performances at the Broadway theatre on Saturday.
City administration is looking to rename a new Saskatoon street after the word was revealed to have different meanings.