Supreme Court sued over its refusal to translate decisions before 1970 into French
The office of the registrar of the Supreme Court of Canada was served with a legal notice on Friday by a Quebec civil rights group challenging the high court's steadfast refusal to translate its historic decisions into French.
Droits collectifs Québec filed an application in Federal Court in Montreal after failing to get the registrar — which serves as the administrative body for the court — to translate the documents.
The lawsuit involves more than 6,000 decisions rendered between 1877 and 1969, the year the Official Languages Act came into effect, requiring federal institutions to publish content in English and in French.
The rights group initially filed a complaint with the official languages commissioner. In response, the Supreme Court, which has been translating decisions since 1970, argued that the law doesn't apply retroactively.
In September, commissioner Raymond Théberge ruled that while the law doesn't apply retroactively, any decisions published on the court's website must be available in both official languages. The failure to translate the judgments amounted to an offence under the act, he said, giving the high court 18 months to correct the situation.
Supreme Court Chief Justice Richard Wagner told reporters in June that the decisions before 1970 are primarily of historical interest, arguing they are "legal cultural heritage made obsolete by the evolution of Quebec and Canadian law." The court lacks the resources to carry out such an operation, he said, adding it would take a decade and cost upwards of $20 million.
The lawyer for the Quebec civil rights group disagrees.
"Court decisions constitute precedents, they bear legal weight, and they have legal meaning, and they will entail legal consequences in the present day," said François Côté, a lawyer from Sherbrooke, Que.
"Even if the law has changed, if new laws were adopted or laws were repealed … what about legal principles? What about legal reasoning?"
Côté's group points to a 1985 Supreme Court ruling that required the government of Manitoba to translate all of the province's laws passed since 1867, regardless of the cost. Etienne-Alexis Boucher, executive director of the group, says he doesn't understand the high court's refusal to translate its historical documents when it has forced other federal institutions to translate theirs.
While the Supreme Court has judicial immunity, the lawsuit instead targets the court's registrar, which is part of the public service.
A spokesman for the Supreme Court said Friday the office of the registrar would not comment since the matter is currently before the courts.
Boucher said his organization is seeking a public apology from the registrar's office to Canadian francophones for not respecting their linguistic rights, and a declaratory judgment recognizing the Supreme Court made a mistake by refusing to translate the historical rulings. As well, the group is seeking a judicial order forcing translations of the rulings within three years of a judgment, conducted by legal translators and not exclusively through the use of artificial intelligence.
The lawsuit is also seeking $1 million in exemplary damages, most of which would go to groups dedicated to preserving the French language.
Côté said it could take several months for the case to make its way through preliminary stages, but he is hopeful for an amicable settlement.
"We are talking about the gatekeeper to the Supreme Court," Côté said. "We are talking about one of the highest state institutions, which must be (held to) the highest, exemplary level."
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 1, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Police find bag carried by gunman who killed UnitedHealthcare's CEO, say he likely fled NYC on bus
Investigators found a backpack in Central Park that was carried by the shooter, police said Friday, following a massive sweep to find it in a vast area with lakes and ponds, meadows, playgrounds and a densely wooded section called 'The Ramble.'
A police photographer recounts the harrowing day of the Polytechnique massacre
Montreal crime scene photographer Harold Rosenberg witnessed a lot of horror over his 30 years on the job, though nothing of the magnitude of what he captured with his lens at the Polytechnique on Dec. 6, 1989. He described the day of the Montreal massacre to CTV Quebec Bureau Chief Genevieve Beauchemin.
Quebec premier wants to ban praying in public
Premier François Legault took advantage of the last day of the parliamentary session on Friday to announce to 'Islamists' that he will 'fight' for Quebec values and possibly use the notwithstanding clause to ban prayer in public places such as parks.
Northern Ontario man sentenced for killing his dog
WARNING: This article contains graphic details of animal abuse which may be upsetting to some readers. A 40-year-old northern Ontario man is avoiding prison after pleading guilty to killing his dog earlier this year.
'Home Alone' house up for sale for US$3.8 million in Chicago suburb – but not the one you're thinking of
Social media sleuths noticed that the house next door to the iconic 'Home Alone' house in Winnetka is now up for sale.
Purolator, UPS pause shipments from couriers amid Canada Post strike
Purolator and UPS have paused shipments from some courier companies as they try to work through a deluge of deliveries brought on by the Canada Post strike.
NDP's Singh forces debate on $250 cheques for more Canadians; Conservatives cut it short
With the fate of the federal government's promised $250 cheques for 18.7 million workers hanging in the balance, the NDP forced a debate Friday on a motion pushing for the prime minister to expand eligibility. The conversation was cut short, though, by Conservative MPs' interventions.
Sask. father who kept daughter from mom to prevent COVID-19 vaccine free from additional prison time
Michael Gordon Jackson, the Saskatchewan father who withheld his then seven-year-old daughter from her mom for nearly 100 days to prevent the girl from getting a COVID-19 vaccine, was handed a 12-month prison sentence and 200 days probation on Friday, but credited with time served.
Did daily cannabis use go up after Canada legalized it?
Health Canada says daily cannabis use has remained stable since it was legalized in 2018.