Quebec wants to tax the unvaccinated, but is that legal?
Some political parties are calling it “radical,” while legal experts are calling it “unprecedented,” but the jury is still out on whether Quebec’s proposal to tax the unvaccinated is legally sound.
In a Canadian first, Quebec Premier François Legault announced a new “health contribution” that will have to be paid by people who haven’t received their first dose of the vaccine for non-medical reasons.
Though the province is still consulting with its minister of finance and legal advisers on the new measure, Legault announced Tuesday during a news conference that it would be a “significant” amount.
- READ MORE: Quebec to impose 'significant' financial penalty against people who refuse to get vaccinated
Montreal-based lawyer Julius Grey told CTV News “there is no question” that it is a clear violation of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, but said he believes if an individual or group challenges it, whether it's upheld in court will be a “close call.”
“On the individual side, this is a major attack on my integrity, my freedom," Grey summarized the argument he predicted, and meanwhile, "there are other things the government could do” to accomplish its goals.
On the other hand, the counter-argument goes, “we’ve tried all sorts of things and Omicron is particularly contagious... and the government would get an expert to say there’s a real threat to the medical system and we might not get beds and so on.”
It's a complicated question, he said.
“It’s not a discriminatory tax. It’s a way of trying to force vaccination, and while that is a clear and major Charter violation, I am not certain what the result will be... It could be argued both ways.”
Timothy Caulfield, law professor and Canada Research Chair in Health Law and Policy at the University of Alberta, said he thinks the validity of a tax on the unvaccinated depends on how it’s implemented.
Such a measure is a “pretty aggressive” move by the government and one that could further polarize public discourse around the vaccines, he said.
“There are certainly reasons to implement incentives and disincentives, but at the same time, this is pretty unprecedented in Canada,” said Caulfield.
“We need to see the details of this policy to get a sense of whether there are any severe legal issues associated with it."
As long as the fee is not tied to access to health care, it doesn't appear to violate the Canada Health Act, he added.
"If it's just a tax that the unvaccinated pay at the end of the year, it's not associated… in any way to access the health-care system," he explained.
That means "it'll probably be less legally problematic, especially if it has appropriate exemptions, appropriate accommodations for those that can't access a vaccine.”
So far, the premier has only said that people who can’t get the vaccine for medical reasons will be exempt from the financial penalty.
Legault justified the controversial decision on Monday by saying the province needs to “go further” than just mandating the vaccine passport to more areas, such as liquor stores and cannabis stores.
Unvaccinated adults "will have a bill to pay because there are consequences on our health-care network and it's not up to all Quebecers to pay for this," the premier said.
"It's a question of equity because right now, these people, they put a very important burden on our health-care network. And I think it's normal that the majority of the population is asking that there be a consequence.”
Caufield said surveys like the one released last week by EKOS Research seem to suggest there is support among Canadians for measures targeting people who are unvaccinated.
The survey found that 66 per cent of people were losing patience with the unvaccinated and 60 per cent reported that tighter restrictions for unvaccinated people make them more hopeful about the COVID-19 pandemic.
“Whatever policy [the Quebec officials] develop has to have appropriate exemptions for those that can't, for medical reasons, for example, access vaccines, or those that have some clear religious exemption, for example," Caulfield said.
"But even there, I anticipate that most courts would see that exemption as being extremely narrow."
In Austria, for example, people 14 and older will face fines of about $5,150 CAD (3,600 Euros) every three months, starting in February, if they're not vaccinated, according to Reuters. Singapore is making the unvaccinated foot the bill for their own COVID-19 medical care.
In Quebec, there are already mechanisms to allow for such policies, according to Paul Brunet, a lawyer and patients’ rights advocate.
“In the law on civil and public security there are already positions where the government can impose obligatory vaccination and impose sanctions[on those] who don't want to get vaccinated, so the setup is there already to be proven to be respectful of the law and constitutional rights,” he said.
Brunet said he supports the premise of the Legault government’s decision, citing the scarce hospital resources in Quebec and the high proportion of unvaccinated people who fill up intensive care beds.
Like Caulfeld, he agreed that personal choices have consequences, though it will be up to the courts to decide if they are justified.
“This is not fair. You have the right to decide what you want to do,” Brunet said, “but if what you’re doing is impacting on anyone else’s health or rights, you are wrong.”
--With files from CTV’s Vanessa Lee, Tania Krywiak and Selena Ross
Montreal Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
As the May long weekend kicked off, a massive thunderstorm in southern Ontario and Quebec brought strong wind gusts that knocked down trees, took out power and left at least four people dead.
The federal government is reporting a sharp rise in influenza in recent months, at a time of the year when detected cases generally start to fall in Canada.
Alberta Premier Jason Kenney says he will not be running in the race to pick a new leader of the United Conservative party.
The United Kingdom's former prime minister Tony Blair says Russian President Vladimir Putin's decision to invade Ukraine is an 'act of madness.' In an interview on CTV's Question Period airing Sunday, Blair said Putin doesn't appear to be the same man he knew in the early 2000s.
Roberta Drury, a 32-year-old woman who was the youngest of the 10 Black people killed at a Buffalo supermarket, was remembered at her funeral Saturday for her love for family and friends, tenacity 'and most of all, that smile that could light up a room.'
Why does smoke seem to follow you around a campfire? B.C. research scientist Kerry Anderson told CTVNews.ca the answer actually boils down to physics.
Some drivers in Toronto may be feeling on edge as Toronto is dealing with a rash of violent carjackings targeting mostly high-end vehicles.
The nightmares started last May, said Harvey McLeod, chief of the Upper Nicola Indian Band and a survivor of the former Kamloops Indian Residential School.
Three people are dead and more than 350,000 are without power after an intense thunderstorm pummeled southern Ontario Saturday afternoon.
Marineland has banned a number of people from its premises, some of whom have never visited the Niagara Falls, Ont., tourist attraction, days before the facility was set to open for the season.
A section of Dartmouth's Burnside Industrial Park was shut down Friday after a fire in a scrapyard triggered alerts and air quality warnings.
Environment Canada is advising New Brunswickers in Edmundston and Madawaska County are to watch for the development of severe thunderstorms Saturday evening.
A few dozen friends, family members, and strangers gathered in Spryfield, N.S., on Saturday to search for a teenager who disappeared three months ago.
A short but powerful thunderstorm that came through Southwestern Ontario Saturday, killing at least one person and injuring others.
It was definitely a night to remember for people in attendance at Labatt Park on Friday evening after a reported gas leak forced the evacuation of the park during the season opener.
The flames were so intense from Thursday’s early morning fire in Hanover that Lisa Schnittker started grabbing her things to evacuate, fearing the flames would spread to her home.
As part of this week’s royal tour, a northern Ontario MP reflects on meeting Prince Charles.
It has been two years since the Northern Ontario Railroad Museum and Heritage Centre in Capreol has been able to put on the Family Fun Big Truck showcase.
Over the next couple of weeks, a telephone survey will be conducted on behalf of the PHU as a follow-up to a survey that was conducted two years ago.
'Won’t open them until we win': Flames fan hopes to pop Champagne bottles meant for '04 Stanley Cup run
It was almost exactly 18 years ago when Calgary Flames fan Shane Byciuk managed to sneak two bottles of Champagne into the Saddledome for Game 6 of the 2004 Stanley Cup finals.
A frost advisory was issued for most of central and southern Alberta by Environment Canada Saturday afternoon.
Ontario Provincial Police are investigating a death in Brant County after a tree fell on a camping trailer on Saturday.
A severe thunderstorm caused extensive damage, fallen trees, downed hydro lines and power outages across Southern Ontario on Saturday.
It’s the first May long weekend since the City of Waterloo made changes to its fireworks bylaw and city staff said some residents are not obeying the new rules.
Firefighters are investigating the cause of a dangerous fire that briefly trapped a Vancouver-area man inside a Tesla.
A social media post is warning young women in Surrey’s Newton neighbourhood to be on high alert, after several have come forward claiming they’ve been followed.
Some British Columbians won’t be getting provincial rebates meant to offset soaring gas prices until the end of July, according to ICBC.
Family members remember one of the men killed in Chinatown this week as a kind and hardworking man, and hope that his needless death will lead to change.
Alberta Premier Jason Kenney says he will not be running in the race to pick a new leader of his United Conservative party.
The Calgary Flames know the recipe they want to follow in their Western Conference second-round playoff series with the Edmonton Oilers.
Every day since the owner of Thanasi's Olympus Greek Restaurant in Windsor, Ont. announced he would be retiring, Nick Pontikis says the place has been packed like it would be on New Year's Eve.
On Friday, the International Union of Operating Engineers ratified a new three-year contract, ending the strike that started in late April.
Bagpipes blared and kilts were worn at Victoria Park in Regina on Saturday for the Highland Gathering and Celtic Festival.
With the construction season in Saskatchewan getting underway; the provincial government laid out its plans to improve approximately 1,100 km of provincial highways in 2022.
Hydro Ottawa says it will take several days to restore power and clean up after a severe storm damaged hydro poles and wires on Saturday.
Two people are dead and at least two others are critically injured after a powerful thunderstorm ripped through Ottawa Saturday afternoon.
The city of Clarence-Rockland, to the east of Ottawa, has declared a state of emergency following a major storm that moved across eastern Ontario on Saturday.
Chief Thunderstick National Hockey Championship in Saskatoon gathers dozens of Indigenous teams from across Canada
From Rankin Inlet, Nunavut to Ochapawace, Saskatchewan, Indigenous hockey teams from all over Canada are in Saskatoon this weekend playing in the Fred Sasakamoose "Chief Thunderstick" National Hockey Championship.