Quebec’s advice on booster shots ‘doesn't make a whole lot of sense,’ public health experts say
Some public health experts are questioning the advice of Quebec’s health ministry, which recommends double-vaccinated people who have just recovered from COVID-19 should get a third dose of the vaccine “as soon as possible.”
In the span of just a couple of months, the province's recommended waiting time between contracting COVID-19 and getting a booster shot went from eight weeks to as soon as your symptoms end.
So, what changed? According to the province, the new guidance is a result of the lack of testing capacity in recent weeks — without the ability to know for sure who had COVID-19, the province wants to err on the side of giving more boosters to more people, even if this goes against the advice of its own medical advisers.
The new advice comes as thousands of new cases have been reported daily through much of December into January during the height of the Omicron surge in the province, but it's puzzling some experts.
“The idea of getting a booster after you had an infection, that's a true COVID infection, doesn't make a whole lot of sense,” said Jamie Scott, a molecular immunologist and professor emeritus at Simon Fraser University.
Scott, whose research focuses on antibody responses to vaccination and natural infection, said someone infected with the novel coronavirus has a “pretty darn huge immune response” and the antibodies in that person would even be far greater than that provided from a third dose based on the scientific literature she has reviewed.
“The other issue is that the booster isn't going to be effective, partly because the antigen made by the vaccine gets cleared. And the other part of it is that since you had your infection, you're developing what are called memory cells," she explained.
"So you’re expanding that [cell] population that was initiated by the vaccine, [it] got expanded by your infection, and that expansion is still happening. And it takes a couple of months for that expansion for those cells to be fully developed.”
Previously, the government-run online booking portal for vaccine appointments, Clic Santé, posted a message on their website for people scheduling their booster shot that said: “If you have had COVID-19, schedule your appointment eight weeks after the beginning of your symptoms or a positive COVID-19 test.”
Now, the website only advises that three months must have passed between someone’s second dose and the third dose, without any guidance on when to book an appointment following a recent infection.
WAITING 2-3 MONTHS RECOMMENDED BY INSPQ, CIQ
Dr. Donald Vinh, an infectious disease specialist at the McGill University Health Centre (MUHC), said the province should be clear about its advice to the public and provide people with consistent health communications during the pandemic.
Both Vinh and Scott agree that booster shots are crucial and key to bolstering the body's defences while the coronavirus is still circulating widely in the community, but say it doesn’t make much sense to rush out and get a booster after symptoms have cleared up from a confirmed COVID-19 infection.
Those people, the experts say, can wait two to three months for a third jab as long as they've already had their two doses.
“If you've been infected, whether or not you were hospitalized, the benefit of the third dose at that point has sort of passed. The horse is already out of the barn,” Vinh said.
"So for a directive, to say 'If you had a recent infection, once your symptoms are over go get your booster dose,' I think it lacks a little bit of the intellectual thought process here."
Another question is which variant infected which people. Early data from South Africa, one of the locations where Omicron first spread, suggest that antibodies from a previous Delta variant infection will not protect you from Omicron — now the predominant variant circulating in Quebec.
Vinh said in an ideal world, everyone would know which variant they were infected with. On the other hand, he said that based on premilinary data it doesn't appear likely that you can be re-infected with Omicron twice, but more research is needed on this front.
“So at this point, there's no obvious reason, immunologically or clinically, to say, ‘Well, you know what, you've had two doses, you've had an infection, then go ahead and get a third dose right now," he maintained.
INSPQ, CIQ RECOMMEND A DELAY
The experts who spoke to CTV News aren’t the only ones who agree that waiting two to three months for a booster shot post-infection is sound advice.
The province’s own public health institute, the INSPQ, and Quebec’s immunization expert panel, the Comité d’immunisation du Québec (CIQ), also recommend delaying the shot for that amount of time.
CTV News asked Quebec’s Ministry of Health and Social Services to explain the shift in guidance on booster shots.
A spokesperson said in a statement that the new guidelines are in part due to the limited testing available to the public. As of right now, PCR testing in screening centres is prioritized for health-care workers, first responders, people who are homeless, and other people in high-risk settings.
During the second half of December, testing sites were overwhelmed almost daily with hundreds of people anxious to get confirmation that they had been infected with the coronavirus.
That means that people often can't be sure if they did really have COVID-19 recently.
“Due to the tightening of access to PCR testing and the limited availability of rapid tests, it is becoming difficult to distinguish between those who have recently had COVID-19 and those who have not," the health ministry's statement said.
Some examples of this are people who develop a respiratory infection other than COVID-19 but can’t get access to a PCR test or one of the sought-after take-home rapid antigen tests to confirm the infection.
Similarly, there are also people who have become infected with the coronavirus, but have little to no symptoms and end up not knowing they were indeed infected.
“In the interest of efficacy, it was therefore decided to remove the delay between infection and the administration of the booster dose," said the ministry.
"It is better to give a booster dose to someone who has recently had COVID-19 than to leave someone who has not had COVID-19 without additional protection."
The statement also acknowledged that if a positive test result is confirmed, that person “could decide to wait three months, the time limit prescribed by the CIQ, before picking up their third dose.”
However, these nuances about testing and positive test results play a key role in someone’s decision of when to book a booster shot, yet they appear nowhere on the provincial government’s website or on Clic Santé.
It’s one of the reasons why some are calling for more transparency on the part of the government when it comes to delivering important health advice to the public.
“I think that a hard reboot may be necessary here to try to figure out what are the different pillars of our strategy here and what are the messages that are going out with respect to these pillars? And are these messages congruent with each other?” Vinh said.
“If you want people to be protected against Omicron, you’ll want to do it before they get infected. But once they get infected, you can't then tell them to go ahead and get vaccinated. It's not really congruent.”
Montreal Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Families are sharing photos and stories of their loved ones, who lost their lives in a mass shooting in Texas that killed at least 19 children and two adults on Tuesday afternoon.
A news conference about the shooting at a Texas elementary school broke into shouting Wednesday as Democratic gunbernatotrial candidate Beto O'Rourke blamed Republican Gov. Greg Abbott for inaction ahead of the latest in a long string of mass shootings in the state.
While genealogical DNA tests may be marketed as harmless and exciting way for people to learn more about their ancestral heritage, CTVNews.ca speaks with a Canadian researcher who says more support is needed for those who get unexpected results that have potential to disrupt family relations.
The gunman who massacred 19 children and two teachers at an elementary school in Texas had warned in online messages minutes before the attack that he had shot his grandmother and was going to shoot up a school, the governor said Wednesday.
Johnny Depp called his ex-wife's accusations of sexual and physical abuse 'insane' Wednesday as he returned to the witness stand in his libel suit against Amber Heard.
Later tonight, the six candidates on the ballot to be the next leader of the Conservative Party of Canada will be debating each other in Laval, Que. CTV News will be live-streaming the debate with English translation and offering real-time updates and analysis, and you can follow along.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau says his 'heart breaks' for those impacted by the 'horrific' shooting at an elementary school in Texas that killed 21 people on Tuesday.
Federal Justice Minister David Lametti says the federal government is prepared to get involved in two controversial Quebec bills, including the language law passed Tuesday, especially if the bills reach the Supreme Court.
With Quebec confirming an additional 10 cases of monkeypox identified in the province, the Public Health Agency of Canada says they are monitoring a total of 15 cases across the country.
Police have released new video of a recent incident in which a vehicle was caught doing doughnuts and speeding along the shoulder of busy Ontario roadways.
Patients at three Toronto hospitals may have had some of their personal data accessed following a cybersecurity breach that was first detected in January.
Toronto Public Health says there are two new suspected cases of monkeypox in the city, as well as one probable case of the virus that's under investigation.
As the inquiry into Nova Scotia’s mass shooting moves its public proceedings to Truro, many of the family members affected by the tragedy and their lawyers are boycotting the proceedings over the next week.
Two more people have been charged with murder in connection with a fatal house fire in Nova Scotia’s Yarmouth County in March. Three people have now been charged in the case.
A man has been arrested in connection with an alleged altercation that sent another man to hospital in Halifax Wednesday morning.
Two men and one woman are facing charges Wednesday after police say their vehicle struck a London police cruiser and then fled the scene on foot over the weekend.
OPP and Southwest Middlesex fire are on the scene of a fatal collision Wednesday afternoon involving a tanker truck and a passenger vehicle.
One person has been taken to hospital with minor injuries after a small SUV and gravel truck collided head-on Wednesday morning.
A candidate in the provincial election in Greater Sudbury has been named in a $306 million lawsuit related to last winter's trucker convoy in Ottawa.
More than three years after it was announced, a date has been set for the inquest into the death of Ronald Charles Lepage, who was killed in Sudbury in 2017 at age 59.
Ontario Provincial Police said Wednesday the remains of one person was discovered following a fire May 22.
The mayor of Calgary says the increase in local gun violence and hate-based crimes needs to be addressed and it's past time the public demand better of its elected officials.
The union representing Calgary Police Service members has directed front-line officers to remove 'thin blue line' patches from their uniforms, its president confirmed Wednesday.
The Calgary Flames RED Lot Community Viewing Party is returning for Game 5 on Thursday at Stampede Park.
Two 29-year-old men have been seriously injured following a collision in Baden, Ont., with one needing to be airlifted to a hospital outside the region.
Nine days after city crews cleaned the latest dumping of red paint off the Queen Victoria statue in Kitchener, the base of the monument is once again covered in the substance.
J F Carmichael Public School will close early Wednesday, the Waterloo Region District School Board said in a tweet posted at 1:20 p.m.
A private member's bill introduced in the British Columbia legislature last week would see the use of proper Indigenous names on provincial identification, something the government says is impossible with the current software.
'It's like walking on Mars to me': B.C. senior still paying mortgage on 'not livable' property after November floods
Months after devastating flooding, a B.C. senior is still paying a mortgage on a home that no longer exists and a property that he says has been assessed at $1.
The B.C. government has released its business case to redevelop the Royal B.C. Museum, after the province faced criticism for its $789-million cost estimate.
An Edmonton themed coffee shop has opened 8,000 kilometres away, owned by a man who lived in the Alberta capital for a decade.
One person has been arrested in connection to an assault in Ponoka on Monday, but police continue to look for two others.
Outdoor pools in Edmonton will open later than in previous years.
Windsor police have arrested another suspect related to the shooting near a Forest Glade bowling alley in April.
The Automotive Parts Manufacturers Association (APMA) is launching the “Future of Work” bursary program aimed at post-secondary students pursuing a future in Canada’s future automotive industry.
Foul play is not suspected after human remains were discovered in Chatham.
A second person is facing murder charges after a man was found dead in a Regina home during a fire investigation in December, the Regina Police Service (RPS) said in a release.
For those looking to hop the border into Manitoba for their camping seasons, it started off on the wrong foot for Duck Mountain Provincial Park.
The City of Regina is considering implementing a rebate program to encourage energy saving and emissions reducing upgrades to residential homes.
The president of Hydro Ottawa says "with a little bit of luck" power will be restored along the Merivale Road area on Thursday, bringing power to another 15,000 to 20,000 customers still in the dark following Saturday's storm.
Hydro One says more than 10,000 customers in Carleton Place have had their power restored after crews repaired the main line powering the town.
The Ottawa Catholic School Board says all schools with power will be open on Thursday, but 14 schools without power will remain closed.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has announced $32 million in funding for long term care in Saskatchewan.
Michael Garnett and his wife Rebecca Rider are on their second trip volunteering in eastern Europe to help Ukrainians affected by Russian invasion.
Several parts of the country, including British Columbia and Canada's Maritime provinces, are likely to see wetter-than-normal conditions this summer, according to AccuWeather's annual summer forecast.