Quebec officer suspended 15 days for throwing away piece of victim's skull
A Quebec provincial police officer has been suspended for 15 days without pay after throwing part of a young motorcycle accident victim's skull into a ravine in 2021.
An administrative judge with the police ethics tribunal found that Sgt. Sébastien Plouffe's misconduct was "inexplicable and unjustifiable," but nevertheless upheld the sentence that had been jointly recommended by the officer and the ethics board investigator.
"The facts of this case demonstrate that Sgt. Sébastien Plouffe failed at his task, at all levels," administrative Judge Benoit Mc Mahon wrote in a Nov. 4 decision.
"His acts of misconduct are disturbing and must be denounced, because they discredit his function and the reputation of his police force."
An agreed statement of facts included in the decision states that the victim's mother found a piece of her 14-year-old son's skull while searching for his cellphone at the site where he had died four days earlier near St-Émile-de-Suffolk, in the province's Outaouais region.
Plouffe responded to her 911 call and collected the remains, but after being criticized by the mother over police handling of the scene, he drove a few kilometres away, walked down a wooded trail and threw the skull part into a ravine. He later lied on a report of his daily activities.
"Such an act denotes insensitivity and a lack of empathy," wrote the judge, who said the officer's actions appeared to have been motivated in part by "revenge."
The police officer's actions were discovered a few days later, when the family tried to get the skull piece back for cremation. Plouffe then admitted his actions, and returned to the woods to search unsuccessfully for the missing piece of bone. More officers were then sent to search, and the fragment was located and sent to the funeral home.
The ethics investigator and the officer had recommended suspensions of 10 and 15 days for two infractions, to be served concurrently. The report noted that Plouffe had admitted wrongdoing, expressed remorse and did not have any other ethical infractions in his 19 years as an officer.
The victim's mother, described in the decision as N.R., challenged the penalty on the grounds that it was too lenient.
Mc Mahon agreed that the sentence was lenient, but he said the tribunal could only overturn a joint recommendation in cases when a penalty is so unreasonable that it's contrary to public interest and could bring the administration of justice into disrepute. Mc Mahon wrote that he did not believe that this bar was met, or that the penalty would lead people to conclude the justice system had ceased to properly function.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Nov. 12, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Potential scenarios for Prime Minister Justin Trudeau and the Liberals
The Liberal government was thrown into disarray this week when Chrystia Freeland stepped down from cabinet as finance minister, reviving calls for Prime Minister Justin Trudeau to step down or call an election.
Will the Amazon strike impact Canadian deliveries?
As Amazon workers at several U.S. facilities begin a strike, Canadian shoppers are likely wondering how the job action will impact their deliveries.
Google Maps image provides clue in Spanish missing persons case
Chance images captured by a passing Google Maps camera showing a man leaning over a large bag or bags in a car trunk with what could be a human body gave police an extra clue in a murder investigation in the central Spanish village of Tajueco.
Gisèle Pelicot speaks after ex-husband found guilty of rapes, sentenced to 20 years in France
Gisele Pelicot spoke of her 'very difficult ordeal' after 51 men were all found guilty Thursday in the drugging-and-rape trial that turned her into a feminist hero, expressing support for other victims of sexual violence whose cases don't get such attention and 'whose stories remain untold.'
WATCH LIVE Man accused in UnitedHealthcare CEO killing expected to appear at hearing on extradition to New York
The suspect charged with shooting to death a health insurance company chief executive on a Manhattan street will be taken Thursday morning to hearings on related Pennsylvania criminal charges and efforts to extradite him to New York.
'This shouldn't happen': Calgary family seeks changes after WestJet accessibility incident
A Calgary woman wants WestJet to apologize to her daughter and to improve staff training on accessibility after an incident during their latest trip.
Mystery drone sightings continue in New Jersey and across the U.S. Here's what we know
A large number of mysterious drones have been reported flying over New Jersey and across the eastern U.S., sparking speculation and concern.
What's the best treatment for ADHD? Large new study offers clues
Stimulant medications and certain therapies are more effective in treating ADHD symptoms than placebos, a new study on more than 14,000 adults has found.
'We'll never be the 51st state,' Premier Ford says following Trump's latest jab
Ontario Premier Doug Ford says Canada will 'never be the 51st state,' rebuking U.S. President-elect Donald Trump’s latest social media post.