Quebec man acquitted of two first-degree murders 46 years later
Claude Paquin woke up Thursday as a free man for the first time in over 40 years after being acquitted of the 1978 first-degree murder of a couple.
"I lived through hell," he told CTV News.
Paquin was sentenced to life in prison in 1983 and his appeal was unsuccessful. He spent 18 years behind bars, then couldn’t go further than 50 kilometers from his home for another 20 or so years.
Paquin stood trial with two other people who were also accused of first-degree murder, one of whom had the charge lessened to being an accessory after the fact.
On Wednesday, Quebec's Crown prosecutor's office declined to try him for a second time for the murders of Ronald Bourgouin and Sylvie Revah.
Paquin said he was innocent from the start and spent years trying to prove it.
Now 81, he said he’s "ready to start a new life" with his name wiped clean.
Case hinged on ‘questionable’ testimony
In 2008, when Paquin got parole, he reached out to Project Innocence Quebec, which offers legal support for the wrongfully convicted.
Nicholas St-Jacques, a criminal defence lawyer with the organization, said there were several red flags in Paquin’s case. So, lawyers started speaking to witnesses and Paquin’s co-accused, looking at court documents and gathering evidence that there was a miscarriage of justice.
It took about 10 years to put everything together and in 2020, Paquin’s lawyers put in a retrial request with the ministry of justice.
What stood out to lawyers, said St-Jacques, was that the case hinged almost entirely on the testimony of Bernard Provençal, a well-known police informant.
But lawyers started noticing contradicting claims in Provençal’s testimony, as well as in the book he later published. There were also disparities between Provençal’s version of events and that of Paquin’s co-accused, who denied that Paquin had ordered and orchestrated the murders.
Paquin’s lawyers got information that strongly suggested the informant was given money and favours from police for his testimony, which wasn’t disclosed to Paquin’s defence team at the time.
"You have to dig a little bit … just the fact that you have that type of witness and there’s nothing else around, that’s a red flag," said St-Jacques, who called Provençal a "very questionable and unreliable witness."
‘Enormous’ consequences
St-Jacques said while the court’s decision Wednesday was a win for Project Innocence Quebec, it was mainly for Paquin.
He said it’s impossible to understand the psychological impact of wrongful convictions, especially when it takes a person’s freedom away for most of their lives. For 41 years, Paquin was known as a murderer.
"It’s a life-changer for him," said St-Jacques.
"Not in the sense that he’s going to do a lot of different things in his life at 81 years old, but that he said all his life he was innocent and now not only he says it, but the court says it."
Though St-Jacques said most miscarriages of justice are corrected in the Court of Appeal, with cases like Paquin "we’re reminded we all have a responsibility" to make sure the legal system works correctly.
"This situation is not unique … the consequences on these individuals are enormous and we cannot fully repair them afterwards," said St-Jacques.
Canada Justice Minister Arif Virani, who decided a miscarriage of justice likely took place in Paquin's case, said "a fair justice system must be compassionate and balance the needs of victims while guarding against potential miscarriages of justice."
"All people living in Canada should have confidence that the justice system is there to protect them and that it can be trusted."
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
'There is no electricity': Canadian travellers in Cuba urge caution in hurricane's wake
Cuba's power grid was knocked out by Hurricane Rafael, which ripped across the country as a Category 3 storm. In western Cuba, it toppled buildings and pushed 50,000 people to find shelter elsewhere. Cubans were already enduring rolling blackouts due to energy shortages.
Sparks fly as MPs question minister on pension implications of proposed election date change
Sparks flew at a parliamentary committee Thursday as MPs questioned Canada's democratic institutions minister about a widely opposed provision in electoral reform legislation that seeks to delay the next fixed election date by one week.
Three charged in One Direction singer Liam Payne's death
Three people have been charged in relation to One Direction singer Liam Payne's death in a fall from his Buenos Aires hotel balcony last month, Argentine authorities said on Thursday.
RCMP already 'on high alert' for potential wave of migrants after Trump election
Canada's federal police force has been preparing for months on a contingency plan for a potential massive influx of migrants across the border following Trump's promise of 'mass deportations' of millions of undocumented immigrants in the U.S.
America votes: How celebrities are reacting to Trump's decisive victory
Celebrities from Hulk Hogan to Ariana Grande are sharing their reactions to the U.S. election, which will see Donald Trump return to the White House.
Volkswagen models recalled for airbag safety precaution
Recall notices have been issued for some Volkswagen models from 2006 to 2019 for airbag safety issues.
3 Winnipeg police officers charged with breach of trust, theft
Three members of the Winnipeg Police Service have been charged with breach of trust, obstruction of justice and theft following a lengthy investigation
Canadian arrested in Florida for allegedly possessing child sex abuse content
A 25-year-old Canadian man was arrested in Florida last weekend after police say he was caught with child sex abuse content.
Biden faces doubts over his legacy as he prepares to hand over power to the man he called a threat to democracy
U.S. President Joe Biden delivered remarks to the nation Thursday in what was his first appearance on camera following Donald Trump’s decisive victory over Kamala Harris.