Quebec cites 'social peace' to extend notwithstanding clause on secularism law
The Quebec government tabled legislation Thursday to continue shielding the province's secularism law -- known as Bill 21 -- from court challenges over Charter violations.
The application of the Constitution's notwithstanding clause for another five years is needed to maintain "social peace" in the province, Jean-Francois Roberge, the minister responsible for secularism, told reporters.
Bill 21 was passed in June 2019 and prohibits public servants deemed to be in positions of authority -- including teachers, police officers and judges -- from wearing religious symbols such as the hijab, turban or kippah on the job. The law sparked outrage among religious minorities across Canada. A challenge to the legislation is currently before the province's highest court, but because of the notwithstanding clause lawyers have been limited in the arguments they can present.
Roberge called Bill 21 an extremely important achievement. "It currently preserves, I would say, social peace, it promotes coexistence. That's why we absolutely must renew the notwithstanding clause," he said.
The Charter of Rights and Freedoms stipulates that the notwithstanding clause -- which protects legislation from challenges over Charter violations -- can be applied to legislation for five years, after which time a government has to renew it.
According to Roberge, Bill 21 has brought "extremely important clarifications for the government, educational institutions, municipalities, courts, police, on what can and cannot be done, the way to handle requests for reasonable accommodations."
Both the Quebec government and groups opposing Bill 21 are challenging an April 2021 Superior Court decision that largely upheld the controversial legislation but struck down provisions relating to English-language school boards and a ban on face coverings for members of the provincial legislature. Seventeen separate parties are challenging the law. The Quebec Court of Appeal heard arguments for and against the law in November 2022 and hasn't yet released a ruling.
The official Opposition Liberals oppose the extension of the notwithstanding clause, saying there is no justification for suspending fundamental freedoms. "The notwithstanding clause … is so broad that it suspends fundamental rights and freedoms that have no connection to Bill 21," said Liberal interim Leader Marc Tanguay.
But the Coalition Avenir Quebec has a majority government, and the other two opposition parties, the Parti Quebecois and Quebec solidaire, also support the extension of the clause.
PQ member Pascal Berube told reporters Thursday that not only does his party like Bill 21, it thinks it should be expanded to cover daycare workers.
Meanwhile, Quebec solidaire spokesman Gabriel Nadeau-Dubois says that while his party doesn't support Bill 21, it also doesn't think the legislation should be struck down over a possible violation of the Canadian Constitution. The law, he said, should be changed by Quebec's legislature.
"It's a bad law for Quebec, but these are debates that must take place in Quebec, which must be settled by Quebec's institutions and charters," Nadeau-Dubois said.
This report by The Canadian Press was first published Feb. 8, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
W5 Investigates Provinces look to Saskatchewan on how to collect millions more for victims of crime
A W5 investigation showed how convicted criminals ordered to pay restitution struggled to do so, and how just $7 million of more than $250 million had been claimed. While many provinces struggle to keep track, Saskatchewan is leading the way in making sure victims get their money.
PM Justin Trudeau planning to oversee sizable cabinet shuffle on Friday: sources
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau is planning a sizable cabinet shuffle on Friday, sources confirm to CTV News. The long-awaited reconfiguration of Trudeau's front bench comes amid turmoil for the Liberal government after the shocking resignation of Chrystia Freeland.
Child struck by vehicle south of London has died
According to an online fundraiser organized by a family friend, the boy who was hit by a driver south of London earlier this week has died.
Who received the longest jail terms in the Gisele Pelicot rape trial?
A French court found all 51 defendants guilty on Thursday in a mass rape case including Dominique Pelicot, who repeatedly drugged his then wife, Gisele, and allowed dozens of strangers into the family home to rape her.
'Tragic and sudden loss': Toronto police ID officer who died after suspected medical episode while on duty
A police officer who died after having a suspected medical episode on duty was executing a search warrant in connection with an ongoing robbery investigation in North York, Toronto police confirmed Thursday.
Manitoba man wins $40M Lotto Max jackpot, among top 5 jackpots in province's history
A Manitoba man has won one of the top five largest lottery jackpots in Manitoba history.
64 cases of 'norovirus-like' illness linked to raw oysters in B.C., officials say
Dozens of people have become ill after eating raw oysters in B.C. since Nov. 1, public health officials warned Thursday.
Conan O'Brien pays tribute to his parents who died within days of each other
Conan O’Brien is remembering his recently deceased parents. In an interview with the Boston Globe, the former late night television host talked about his mother, Ruth Reardon O’Brien, who died last Thursday, and Dr. Thomas F. O’Brien, who preceded his wife in death three days earlier.
N.B. Liberal government revises Policy 713, parental consent no longer required for students' preferred names
The New Brunswick Liberals are reversing course on the previous government’s decision to change Policy 713.