Public transport: no money wasted, but $346 million in savings are possible
The province's 10 public transport companies could eventually save a total of $346 million, but this will require a change in operating methods and probably some serious arm-wrestling between the companies and their unions.
However, the 515-page performance audit delivered on Thursday by the firm Raymond Chabot Grant Thornton found that these companies, as well as the Autorité régionale de transport métropolitain (ARTM), are well managed.
“We have not come to the conclusion that the transport companies are wasting taxpayers’ money,” said Nicolas Plante, principal author of the report, thereby putting the lid on the idea that these organizations sometimes spend recklessly.
Unsustainable deficit
In her presentation of the audit, Transport Minister Geneviève Guilbault pointed out that based on current projections, public transport companies in the Montreal region are projecting an accumulated deficit of $2.5 billion by 2028, a deficit she described as “unsustainable.”
“We can hardly do without it. We need that $346 million,” she said.
Many of the increases in operating costs are partly unavoidable, including items such as the price of fuel, which has soared over the five-year period studied. However, the largest transport companies manage to obtain price reductions due to the volume of their purchases, an advantage that the others could also benefit from by pooling their purchases.
Furthermore, both the audit and the minister pointed out that 64 per cent of transport companies' expenditure is on wages. Without putting a figure on the value of certain changes, the audit nevertheless identifies certain obstacles to the implementation of certain measures in the collective agreements.
Lack of flexibility
“Among the recommendations to be prioritized in the shorter or medium term that would be the most concrete and quickest to implement, there are some that are limited by collective agreement clauses that prevent us from having the necessary flexibility to take certain actions that would generate savings,” Guilbault said.
Frédéric Therrien, president of the bus drivers‘ and metro operators’ union at the Société de transport de Montréal (STM), was waiting for journalists after the audit presentation to denounce the fact that, in his opinion, “the cuts are still being made on the backs of the workers and on the backs of the customers,”
“I find it appalling that the CAQ government says that for them, it is important to have good, quality jobs, but every time there is a need to save money, it’s at the expense of workers,” Therrien said.
As for the required flexibility referred to in the audit, he responded that his union had always negotiated in good faith, but that “the minister pushes us to the limit by saying that we are not flexible.”
“But discussing this during negotiations will be our pleasure," he said, adding that negotiations with the STM have just begun as the collective agreement for his members expires on January 5.
His reaction, however, signals what can be expected across all transport companies in the province.
Too many unused vehicles
One of the most significant savings identified in the report, that could be achieved in the short term, would be addressing what is called “the reserve rate,” meaning the surplus number of vehicles that are either stored in anticipation of need or undergoing maintenance.
According to the audit, the optimal ratio is 20 per cent, but some transport companies, such as those in the Outaouais (61 per cent), Saguenay (44 per cent), the capital (43 per cent) and Montreal (41 per cent), far exceed this target, resulting in costs that could be reduced.
Guilbault also expressed willingness to review timelines for electrifying bus fleets "to reduce the pressure," as this represents a major expense for transit agencies—not only for vehicle purchases but also for building new garages for their maintenance.
Another approach aims to reduce service frequency on less busy routes at certain times and even introduce on-demand transit, a model growing in popularity but often involving outsourcing to private companies.
"Private providers can be beneficial," said Guilbault, while acknowledging that this, too, could lead to pushback from unions.
Notably, of the $346 million identified as potential savings, the audit details only $166 million, with the remaining $180 million identified by transit agencies themselves.
The breakdown of this amount "is confidential," officials said several times.
This report was first published in French by The Canadian Press Nov. 7, 2024.
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
Canadian team told Trump's tariffs unavoidable in short term in surprise Mar-a-Lago meeting
During a surprise dinner at Mar-a-Lago, representatives of the federal government were told U.S. tariffs from the incoming Donald Trump administration cannot be avoided in the immediate term, two government sources tell CTV News.
Toronto man accused of posing as surgeon, performing cosmetic procedures on several women
A 29-year-old Toronto man has been charged after allegedly posing as a surgeon and providing cosmetic procedures on several women.
Saskatoon priest accused of sexual assault says he meant to encourage young girl with hug and kiss
A Saskatoon priest accused of sexual assault says he meant to encourage and reassure a young girl when he hugged and kissed during his testimony at Saskatoon Provincial Court Friday.
W5 Investigates 'I never took part in beheadings': Canadian ISIS sniper has warning about future of terror group
An admitted Canadian ISIS sniper held in one of northeast Syria’s highest-security prisons has issued a stark warning about the potential resurgence of the terror group.
Trump threatens 100% tariff on the BRIC bloc of nations if they act to undermine U.S. dollar
U.S. president-elect Donald Trump on Saturday threatened 100 per cent tariffs against a bloc of nine nations if they act to undermine the U.S. dollar.
'Disappointing': Toronto speed camera cut down less than 24 hours after being reinstalled
A Toronto speed camera notorious for issuing tens of thousands of tickets to drivers has been cut down again less than 24 hours after it was reinstalled.
Bruce the tiny Vancouver parrot lands internet fame with abstract art
Mononymous painter Bruce has carved a lucrative niche on social media with his abstract artworks, crafted entirely from the colourful juices of fruits.
Poilievre suggests Trudeau is too weak to engage with Trump, Ford won't go there
While federal Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre has taken aim at Prime Minister Justin Trudeau this week, calling him too 'weak' to engage with U.S. president-elect Donald Trump, Ontario Premier Doug Ford declined to echo the characterization in an exclusive Canadian broadcast interview set to air this Sunday on CTV's Question Period.
Why this Toronto man ran so a giant stickman could dance
Colleagues would ask Duncan McCabe if he was training for a marathon, but, really, the 32-year-old accountant was committing multiple hours of his week, for 10 months, to stylistically run on the same few streets in Toronto's west end with absolutely no race in mind. It was all for the sake of creating a seconds-long animation of a dancing stickman for Strava.