Judge dismisses Quebec woman's lawsuit against Trudeau after he blasted her 'racism'
A Quebec judge has thrown out a defamation lawsuit launched by a Quebec woman who argued that Prime Minister Justin Trudeau violated her rights when he called out her “racism” during a Liberal Party rally in 2018.
Diane Blain, of Saint-Jean-sur-Richelieu, Que., took the prime minister to court alleging that his comments in public violated her rights to freedom of expression and personal dignity. She sought $90,000 in damages.
In his written ruling on Monday, Superior Court Justice Michele Monast said the lawsuit was “ill-founded” and “abusive” and that the only person to blame for negative comments made about the incident is herself.
“Ms. Blain appears to have used the August 16, 2018 event to gain notoriety and promote her political views," wrote Justice Monast in the decision.
"It is not unreasonable to conclude, as suggested by Mr. Trudeau's counsel, that she took legal action against him for the same reasons."
The woman was filmed shouting at Trudeau in French during the rally for Liberal supporters and volunteers in Sainte-Anne-de-Sabrevois, Que.
She challenged him on the federal government’s immigration policy, particularly the amount of money he’d given to “illegal immigrants” in reference to asylum seekers at the Roxam Road border crossing.
At the time, the Quebec government had said a recent influx of people at the border had cost the province around $146 million and it had sought reimbursement from the federal government.
"That intolerance with regard to immigrants doesn't belong in Canada. That intolerance with regard to diversity, you don't belong here," Trudeau said in response.
"Madame, your intolerance doesn't belong here."
That’s when she responded by asking if he was tolerant of “Quebecois de souche,” a term used to describe Quebecers who can trace their roots to the earliest French settlers, which would exclude recent immigrants and Indigenous peoples.
“Madame, your racism has no place here,” the prime minister fired back to an applause from the crowd. The court ruling noted that that crowd included several people from diverse backgrounds and immigrants.
When she replied, “You don’t belong in Quebec either,” Trudeau told her that he was a “proud Quebecer.”
WOMAN WAS ‘TRYING TO PROVOKE HIM’
Blain testified that the incident was the most humiliating moment of her life and told the court that she’s “not racist.”
“I'm tolerant. I'm a nurse, I care for people who are yellow, red or Black,” she said in her testimony. “I have empathy.”
Blain had alleged that her reputation was tarnished by Trudeau’s comments, but the judge said she failed to provide any evidence to support her claims.
On the contrary, the court entered into evidence some of her social media posts that showed she had boasted about her confrontation with the prime minister, that her Facebook following had grown, that she had been invited to give speeches and had done interviews with right-wing publications following the incident.
In one of her Facebook posts, she discussed her refusal to be served by a Muslim woman “wearing the veil” during an appointment at the Université de Montréal and encouraged her friends to do the same.
In another post, she shared a video of her confrontation with Trudeau and the comment: “I am intolerant of injustice and the destruction of the Quebec nation.”
“In reality, she planned and orchestrated her presence at this rally with another person whose extreme right-wing nationalist ideology she shares. Their intention was to disrupt the event and prevent Mr. Trudeau from addressing his supporters,” the court ruling said.
“Her lack of civility, the aggressive tone in which she asked her questions, her insistence that Mr. Trudeau answer her immediately while he was delivering a speech, the disorder caused by her repeated questions, her refusal to not let him speak and listen to him, in spite of requests to do so, and in general her hostile attitude showed that she was trying to provoke him.”
According to court documents, Trudeau said in submitted testimony that the context in which Blain’s questions were asked was “important.”
“It was a context in which the goal was to disrupt and push an agenda that was either anti-immigrant or just wanted to create fear or concern about immigrants," the prime minister said.
"So for me, it was important that I respond firmly and clearly."
The prime minister’s comments may have offended Blain, but the court found they were not defamatory given her past behaviour and the choice of words she chose to challenge Trudeau.
Blain also claimed that the aftermath of the confrontation also strained her relationship with her daughter, who said she was “embarrassed” by her mother.
However, the court cast the claim as “implausible” and that any effect on the relationship was caused by “her own behaviour."
Justice Monast tossed the case out and ordered Blain to pay her own legal fees.
Montreal Top Stories
CTVNews.ca Top Stories
LIVE COVERAGE | 'My little love is now flying high': Families pay tribute to Texas school shooting victims
Families are sharing photos and stories of their loved ones, who lost their lives in a mass shooting in Texas that killed at least 19 children and two adults on Tuesday afternoon.
A news conference about the shooting at a Texas elementary school broke into shouting Wednesday as Democratic gubernatorial candidate Beto O'Rourke blamed Republican Gov. Greg Abbott for inaction ahead of the latest in a long string of mass shootings in the state.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau cancelled plans to appear in person at a Liberal fundraiser in British Columbia Tuesday after RCMP warned an aggressive protest outside the event could escalate if he arrived, said a source close to the decision. The source spoke to The Canadian Press on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to discuss the situation publicly.
The gunman who massacred 19 children and two teachers at an elementary school in Texas had warned in online messages minutes before the attack that he had shot his grandmother and was going to shoot up a school, the governor said Wednesday.
Do oil companies control the price of crude? CTVNews.ca asked experts to explain.
Several parts of the country, including British Columbia and Canada's Maritime provinces, are likely to see wetter-than-normal conditions this summer, according to AccuWeather's annual summer forecast.
Later tonight, the six candidates on the ballot to be the next leader of the Conservative Party of Canada will be debating each other in Laval, Que. CTV News will be live-streaming the debate with English translation and offering real-time updates and analysis, and you can follow along.
A jury in Portland has convicted a self-published romance novelist - who once wrote an essay titled 'How to Murder Your Husband' - of fatally shooting her husband four years ago.
The Public Health Agency of Canada says it has now confirmed a total of 16 cases of monkeypox in the country, all in Quebec.
Was your home damaged by the Ontario storm? Insurance companies say payouts could take weeks to process
The insurance industry says it could take up to six weeks to get an idea of how many hundreds of millions of dollars in pay outs will be required from the weekend storm that brought death and destruction to Ontario and Quebec, but that early estimates are substantial.
Police have released new video of a recent incident in which a vehicle was caught doing doughnuts and speeding along the shoulder of busy Ontario roadways.
People all across Ontario are getting creative when it comes to netting a secondary income, otherwise known as a “side hustle,” and many are turning to secondhand economies thriving on online platforms.
As the inquiry into Nova Scotia’s mass shooting moves its public proceedings to Truro, many of the family members affected by the tragedy and their lawyers are boycotting the proceedings over the next week.
Former Chief Anchor Steve Murphy offers a timely perspective on the Mass Casualty Commission and the difference 30 years after the Westray inquiry.
Two more people have been charged with murder in connection with a fatal house fire in Nova Scotia’s Yarmouth County in March. Three people have now been charged in the case.
Two men and one woman are facing charges Wednesday after police say their vehicle struck a London police cruiser and then fled the scene on foot over the weekend.
OPP and Southwest Middlesex fire are on the scene of a fatal collision Wednesday afternoon involving a tanker truck and a passenger vehicle.
Jeff Ducharme was in his home office when a young man in a truck pulled up, ran up to the front of his home in Norwich, Ont. and stole his pride flag in broad daylight.
A candidate in the provincial election in Greater Sudbury has been named in a $306 million lawsuit related to last winter's trucker convoy in Ottawa.
The partnership between the Sudbury Theatre Centre and YES Theatre has many people wondering what it means for arts in the city -- and why it was put in place without consulting the arts community first.
An Orillia man responsible for causing a head-on collision when he drove the wrong way on Highway 11 four years ago, sending a woman to the hospital with life-altering injuries, has been acquitted.
Those who haven't receive their bill by the first week of June are asked to contact 311.
Milan Lucic is a veteran of 135 Stanley Cup playoff games and has seen it all through the years. He's been up three games to none in a series and lost. He's also been up three games to one and had to play a seventh game.
The mayor of Calgary says the increase in local gun violence and hate-based crimes needs to be addressed and it's past time the public demand better of its elected officials.
New details are emerging about the tragic incident that killed 27-year-old Shelby Humble-Neale on Saturday.
Two 29-year-old men have been seriously injured following a collision in Baden, Ont., with one needing to be airlifted to a hospital outside the region.
Nine days after city crews cleaned the latest dumping of paint off the Queen Victoria statue in Kitchener, the base of the monument is once again covered in red.
Ryan Reynolds shared some of what it was like growing up in Vancouver in a new interview with David Letterman this week, including the fact that he said he was going out to get gas when what he was really doing was moving to Los Angeles.
B.C. committee recommends honorary degree given to principal of former residential school be rescinded
A sub-committee formed by the University of British Columbia has recommended the honorary degree granted to a former principal of a residential school where unmarked graves were detected last year be rescinded.
B.C. woman's 'elaborately concocted alibi' for hit-and-run included fake letters, false accusations, court says
A B.C. woman who was convicted of a fatal hit-and-run despite her "elaborately concocted alibi" which included forged letters and lying about her truck being stolen by a panhandler, has lost her bid to have her sentence reduced.
Even though they cheer for opposite teams, a proposal by a Flames fan at Game 4 of the Battle of Alberta received a resounding "yes" from the Oilers-loving bride to be.
"Blunt force injuries" have been determined as the cause of death for both men attacked in Edmonton's Chinatown on May 19.
Alberta's justice minister is facing criticism for "strange" and "remarkably unhelpful" comments he made in the legislature on Tuesday when an NDP MLA asked him to help fight crime in Chinatown.
Helping students break down academic and social barriers, more Temi robots coming to St. Clair College
The Community Integration through Cooperative Education (CICE) program at St. Clair College received a $20,000 boost Wednesday morning.
Windsor police arrest final suspect sought in Forest Glade shooting, Major Crimes Unit continues investigation
Windsor police have arrested another suspect related to the shooting near a Forest Glade bowling alley in April.
The Town of Amherstburg is testing a pilot project with Transit Windsor for service in the town.
A new art exhibit at the George Bothwell Library is hoping to examine and remove the feeling of shame associated with people who are deaf and hard of hearing.
For those looking to hop the border into Manitoba for their camping seasons, it started off on the wrong foot for Duck Mountain Provincial Park.
The City of Regina is considering implementing a rebate program to encourage energy saving and emissions reducing upgrades to residential homes.
The president of Hydro Ottawa says "with a little bit of luck" power will be restored along the Merivale Road area on Thursday, bringing power to another 15,000 to 20,000 customers still in the dark following Saturday's storm.
The Ottawa Catholic School Board says all schools with power will be open on Thursday, but 14 schools without power will remain closed.
Out of the tragedy of Saturday’s storm, come stories of people helping each other.
Prime Minister Justin Trudeau has announced $32 million in funding for long term care in Saskatchewan.
Saskatoon Police Service says that the use and presence of potent new synthetic opioids known as nitazenes are difficult to track and monitor.
A 48-year-old semi-truck driver was killed in in a rollover near Meadow Lake on Tuesday.